This is an interesting question. The issue is not really one of "gold box" - "white box" as it is one of ascertaining the relative compression ratio of the various motors. In a prior post, it was agreed upon and rightly so, that this can only be accurately ascertained with a simple compression test.
As to desirability, there is none!!! It is simply a matter of personal preference!! My Saito 72 has been modified to give me an "old school" Supertigre 46 type of run which I like, (hey, I'm older LOL). Whatever floats your boat.
I do feel that if you are going to get serious about 4 bangers, especially the big ones, you should amassed enough experience to know what type type of run you like. I strongly felt I needed to "bring down" my 72. I feel the 40A is PERFECT for me out of the box.