I know this probably isn't going to help Andrew.... but I just maidened a Score w/ST 51 today. Its not my plane, but I did put it all together for the owner.... so I got the first few flights on it. It went together ok, but I did replace some hardware that was in the kit. Nothing fancy, just stuff that worked better. I did my best on flap/elevator alignment, and set linkages and throws exactly per the book. The leadouts were placed in the middle of each respective slot. CG set at 4 1/8" from LE, and 1oz of weight on the outboard tip. Stock muffler (replacing w/Tongue next week), APC 11x6, and 10% Nitro/25% Castor. 60 ft lines ....
Ran the motor in 3 times on the bench ..... 3oz at a time. Did NOT run well at first, but by the 3rd 3oz bench-run, it had settled down nicely. Between the owner and myself..... we put up 7 flights before one of the landing gear blocks gave way on a hard landing.
The last several flights, the wind had kicked up to 15mph or so ...... still flew pretty well in that breeze. I did several wingovers, and while the lines did get light, it wasn't anything that had me looking to clean my shorts. On my last flight (#6) I flew inverted a few laps and did a couple of horiz-8's ..... and the motor was just starting to show a 4-2-4 break. After the flight, the owner asked about that and thought it sounded cool. LOL!
Of course it has some trim issues to take care of, but considering what we put it through today (including the wind), it was 100% successful and the owner is extremely happy. It does pull hard on level flight, and takeoffs/landings seem to be a breeze! (Except the last landing .... ballooning up into the wind makes for a hard landing. LOL!)
Andrew, sorry I didn't get any RPM readings. I'll try to remember to grab my tach tomorrow. Landing gear is all fixed so we'll be taking it up again. I know this isn't helping you much (except rubbing it in, which is NOT intentional), but my point is that I built this Score per the manual, so there wasn't anything funky about the setup of plane or motor ....
Hope you get it sorted out ...... you've got something unusual going on !!
Fly Safe! Larry (Larrys4227)