Well at least he did boil and color them himself, I think that qualifies under the COE (cultivator of egg) rules. In my area we don't call them Almost Ready to Fry eggs, we have the RTH (Ready to Hide) and ARC (Almost Ready to Color) eggs. The RTH eggs come already boiled and colored. They only require a few minutes of prepartion to put them in the baskets and they are ready to hide, these do not qualify for COE. The ARC are not boiled or colored. You have to boil them then color them before they are ready to hide. Now although the ARC eggs are store bought and not self cultivated, they do under the current EEH (Easter Egg Hiders) rules qualify for COE.
I personally do not feel that the the ARC eggs should qualify. A true EEH should cultivate his own eggs from chickens that he lovingly feeds and cares for himself. Self cultivation is the only way to truly learn to appreciate the art and sport of Easter Egg Hiding. Buying RTH and ARC eggs is cheating and is an insult to the hider who has taken the time and patience to cultivate his own eggs. It discourages advances and innovation in the cultivation of top quality eggs.
So, this is my point. Do we want to make our sport only about the hiding of the eggs? Or, do we want the cultivation and coloring to be the focus of the sport? I think the cultivation and coloring are much more important. You see, anyone can hide an egg, but it takes a true craftsman to culitivate and properly color easter eggs. I am a proud cultivator of all my own eggs. My 2 cents, your opinions may vary.