Masking tape does have some grab but I think his problem is with paint adhesion. I use different kinds of tape on my planes, I think it is all 3M but I use masking tape, the blue thin line tape (which I have had more pullups with than any other tape), and I use the blue "edge lock" painters tape that you can buy at your local hardware store or Walmart. All three have there own uses but like I said in the beginning, if the paint does not adhere you are screwed no matter what you use.
Pat, could you explain the process you used so we can understand it a little better?
Derek