It was great day, beautiful fall weather on a super field, Brad LaPoints' farm near Dresden.
There were 11 combat entries, pretty good by modern standards, including the usual pros, plus the return of Bill Trumbel, several scale, stunt and racing pilots upgrading to "fighter status" and junior contestant Dan Birks. There were 22 matches, the same number as in full double elim.
Under the "4 round" format, everybody flys 4 matches for points, win or lose. Thus the "losers" don't have just one or two flights for their effort and the winners don't use up 5-to-8 matches worth of planes.
The ultimate winner was (not surprisingly) Ivan MacKenzie, with 8 cuts and most of the available 16 minutes of airtime.
We did not offer the bonus for a "clean" match, just cuts and airtime. We figured that a collision or line tangle robs you of airtime and gives up the ability to score cuts. So why rub it in with a 200-point penalty to boot?
Unlike other 4-rounders, we flew the first three rounds by random draw and only matched "close scores" in the 4th and final match.
For the new young guys in the world of combat there was a demonstation of a SuperTigre G21 spitting out a crankshaft. Who says there's no new blood in combat? The majority of those in attendance hadn't seen it before. Time flys.
One glaring defect in the "points combat" system is the lack of DEFENSE. A scoring system that rewards only the most points scored gives no incentive to defend your streamer. Thus, in the later rounds, 3 and even 4 cuts were yielded. This loophole needs to be plugged. Suggestions include:
Giving points only for the net difference in cuts.
Giving 100 for scoring a cut, but lose 50 for giving one up.
A bonus for scoring more points (winning) the match.
The system was well-liked by most people, except for the issue of defense.
The engines included one Fox 36 Mark IV, one ST G21/35, one Brodak 25, and all the rest OS/Thunder Tigre/GP/Magnum 25's.
Film at eleven.