News:

 

CLICK HERE--><--CLICK HERE

Unequal panels

Started by Charlie Pate, June 08, 2006, 11:57:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 8 Guests are viewing this topic.

Charlie Pate

 Many planes are built with the inboard wing panel longer than the outboard wing
panel.
The reason for this is said to equalise lift on both wings as the outboard panel
moves faster than the inboard panel.
If this be true, why doesn,t the same thing apply to the stab;or , why don,t we make the inside stab panel longer to give equal lift like the wing?
Just a thought.

minnesotamodeler

I don't think anyone has an answer for you!  I have heard this apparent inconsistency discussed before, but never with any kind of resolution.  Maybe you ought to do some experimenting with it and see how (if) it affects flight characteristics.

--Ray
--Ray 
Roseville MN (St. Paul suburb, Arctic Circle)
AMA902472

Tom Dugan

Charlie,

I am far from the expert but I can tell you that Ray has summed it up in a few short sentences.  This comes up in all the forums and there is definately a difference of opinion.  I think you will see that it is the older models that have very obvious offset.  The purpose was to create extra lift to counteract many of the forces acting on a CL plane.  The plan or kit you are looking at probably has 2" offset and again is an older design kit.  It seems that newer designs do not have offset and if they do it may be 1/2".  In the forum discussions I have seen offset boils down to three choices and for the most part are personal preference.  Those choices are:

1.  Leave the offset in the kit as it was designed.  The designer decided that it gives the plane the best flight characteristics.

2.  Thinking about offset currently is that if you put offset in, only 1/2" is really needed.

3.  No offset is needed.

These choices are what Ive taken away from the several threads that Ive read so far.  I know this doesnt answer your question but current opinion is split just about evenly around these personal preference choices.

Thomas

Russell Shaffer

I always thought it was to offset the weight of the lines.  Same reason for tip weight.  But I'm certainly no aeronautical engineer.
Russell Shaffer
Klamath Falls, Oregon
Just North of the California border

Brett Buck

Quote from: Charlie Pate on June 08, 2006, 11:57:35 AM
Many planes are built with the inboard wing panel longer than the outboard wing
panel.
The reason for this is said to equalise lift on both wings as the outboard panel
moves faster than the inboard panel.
If this be true, why doesn,t the same thing apply to the stab;or , why don,t we make the inside stab panel longer to give equal lift like the wing?


    That's a very interesting thought. I have come to the opinion that this effect is responsible for the common need to have a larger outboard flap.

      Brett

Bill Little

Quote from: Brett Buck on June 08, 2006, 10:53:14 PM
    That's a very interesting thought. I have come to the opinion that this effect is responsible for the common need to have a larger outboard flap.

      Brett

Brett,

Since the reaction of the airplane is to nose out when up is applied and nose in when down is applied  (counterclockwise flight), doesn't the increase in outboard flap area help to some degree to offset this?  It seems to me that with a larger outboard flap area, when the flaps are deflected it almost gives an "aileron" effect to the plane.  I do not see the added flap area outboard to be of that great an advantage in level flight other than to maybe support a *little* more tip weight..

Am I way off base here??

(Sorry Charlie)

Bill <><
Big Bear <><

Aberdeen, NC

James Hylton Motorsports/NASCAR/ARCA

AMA 95351 (got one of my old numbers back! ;D )

Trying to get by

Brett Buck

Quote from: Bill Little on June 09, 2006, 06:09:43 PM
Brett,

Since the reaction of the airplane is to nose out when up is applied and nose in when down is applied  (counterclockwise flight), doesn't the increase in outboard flap area help to some degree to offset this? 

   I don't think so - the extra drag, if any, will nose the airplane out with turns in either direction, so it will make one direction worse.
     Note I didn't commit myself to which direction it yaws in corners. There is more than one effect, and I'll let Ted and Al argue over that one some more.


  The asymmetrical torque in *roll* from the effect Charlie mentions results in the airplane rolling away from you (as if you had more tip weight) on either insides or outsides. The larger outboard flap counters this.

    I have done some pretty crude experiments with this in the last few years, with stab/elevator extensions on the inboard side. They were so cursory that I didn't really prove anything one way or the other. It's a very minor effect, and to really make a complete experiment you really need to replace the outboard flap with one the same size as the inboard.

      Brett
   

Bill Little

Quote from: Brett Buck on June 09, 2006, 10:57:45 PM
   I don't think so - the extra drag, if any, will nose the airplane out with turns in either direction, so it will make one direction worse.
     Note I didn't commit myself to which direction it yaws in corners. There is more than one effect, and I'll let Ted and Al argue over that one some more.


  The asymmetrical torque in *roll* from the effect Charlie mentions results in the airplane rolling away from you (as if you had more tip weight) on either insides or outsides. The larger outboard flap counters this.

    I have done some pretty crude experiments with this in the last few years, with stab/elevator extensions on the inboard side. They were so cursory that I didn't really prove anything one way or the other. It's a very minor effect, and to really make a complete experiment you really need to replace the outboard flap with one the same size as the inboard.

      Brett

Thanks, Brett.  I had not figured the drag of the flap, just the increased size. 

Haven't seen Ted and Al discuss all the "P" words in quite a while!

The experiment you speak of would seem to have been simple with something like Ted's Imitation and the variable flap size set up he started with.  (??)

Bill <><
Big Bear <><

Aberdeen, NC

James Hylton Motorsports/NASCAR/ARCA

AMA 95351 (got one of my old numbers back! ;D )

Trying to get by

Brett Buck

Quote from: Bill Little on June 10, 2006, 09:17:28 AM

The experiment you speak of would seem to have been simple with something like Ted's Imitation and the variable flap size set up he started with.  (??)


   We would have to have thought of it before the airplane met it's demise.

    It was one of the points of evidence in the idea. The airplane was rather famous for outrageous twist in the fuselage, and it tended to be in the direction indicated by the lift asymmetry in the tail. If you see the tail twisted 20-30 degrees, you can figure it's putting a lot of torque on the rest of the airplane.

      Brett

Terry Fancher

Quote from: Bill Little on June 10, 2006, 09:17:28 AM
Thanks, Brett.  I had not figured the drag of the flap, just the increased size. 

Haven't seen Ted and Al discuss all the "P" words in quite a while!

The experiment you speak of would seem to have been simple with something like Ted's Imitation and the variable flap size set up he started with.  (??)

Bill <><

Bill,

We're keeping our powder dry! >:D >:D >:D

Ted  p.s. The "currently being contemplated" twin Imitation will not have the tail twist problems addressed by my esteemed colleague.  It will, in fact, have a built up fuse (and may actually have a slightly longer inboard stab/elev.  As you might have guessed, Brett and I have spent more than a few minutes discussing the possibility)

p.p.p.s.  Actually, I thought the Imitation was famous for being a truly great design and flying outstanding patterns. ::) ::) ::) .  Guess maybe I was blinded by the twisting tail.  8)

Bill Little

Hi Ted,

ALL of the Imitations I have seen in the air have been outstanding flyers!  So much so that I have sheeted a set of ancient foam cores to biuld an OS 40VF piped version.  Probably leaving it as a profile!

Bill <><
Big Bear <><

Aberdeen, NC

James Hylton Motorsports/NASCAR/ARCA

AMA 95351 (got one of my old numbers back! ;D )

Trying to get by

Terry Fancher

Quote from: Bill Little on June 13, 2006, 11:08:36 AM
Hi Ted,

ALL of the Imitations I have seen in the air have been outstanding flyers!  So much so that I have sheeted a set of ancient foam cores to biuld an OS 40VF piped version.  Probably leaving it as a profile!

Bill <><

Bill,

I'm sure you'll enjoy it.  I probably flew my original at least twice as many flights as any other airplane I've built.  It was the easiest airplane to fly well I've ever flown and wasn't critical to trim.  My favorite configuration was with the Enya .46 four stroke that was an absolutely perfect combination despite the resulting high weight (about 62 oz with the four stroke up front and the weight in the tail necessary to balance it).  YOu could do any maneuver you wanted any size you wanted and it just kept chugging along.

All kidding aside, Brett's admonition about the flexible aft fuse is real.  From the pilot's perspective it never bothered my with my original but, from watching others fly theirs, it was very real.  Anything of reasonable weight that can be done to add some torsional rigidity would probably be worth it.

A local flyer, Paul Pomposo, has been flying one of late with a piped VF and seems to like it a lot.

Ted

L0U CRANE

Hi, all...

I favor unequal  wing panel physical lengths that are dynamically equal in area, considering the span and flight radius.

There's no single rule of thumb for that condition, although many models are very similar in layout, line length and span, so for them the same solution works or is very close.

As I recall, many designers went to equal-physical-length panels for appearance reasons, then found that they needed quite a bit more tipweight than the (properly sized) unequal panels did. I think, also, experimenting with larger outboard flap area also began with "equal span panels," then was found useful for "unequal-span-panels."

If the panel area is split properly to each side of the fuselage, many of the lift, drag and thrust problems are pretty well resolved.

Since the line weight acts vertically, and line drag in flight acts horizontally, we can static-balance the effect of line weight with tipweight (I presume the model carries half and I carry the other half. Of course, that applies  less and less as the model moves higher on the flight hemisphere, but it is a starting point.)

We deal with the horizontal effect of line drag with CG position vs leadout guide location, and a few other things...
\BEST\LOU

Paul Smith

I built a certain combat design with 1.5" of offset.  I built a lot of 'em, maybe 20 or so.

Just as an experiment, after listening to this "equal panel" jive, I built one with equal panels. A total disaster !!!  It came on the lines like crazy.  I had to add 2 ounces of tip weight. 

Reason ?? Simple.  The outboard wing is going faster and makes lot more lift.  In tight turns, it makes so much excess lift, it will come into the centre and EAT YOU.

I cured it by cutting 1.5" off the outboard wing and return the tip weight to normal.

The old masters got right.  Some kits are made equal just to minimize production cost.
Paul Smith

Brett Buck

Quote from: ama21835 on July 13, 2006, 03:58:32 AM
I built a certain combat design with 1.5" of offset.  I built a lot of 'em, maybe 20 or so.

Just as an experiment, after listening to this "equal panel" jive, I built one with equal panels. A total disaster !!!  It came on the lines like crazy.  I had to add 2 ounces of tip weight. 

Reason ?? Simple.  The outboard wing is going faster and makes lot more lift.  In tight turns, it makes so much excess lift, it will come into the centre and EAT YOU.

I cured it by cutting 1.5" off the outboard wing and return the tip weight to normal.

The old masters got right.  Some kits are made equal just to minimize production cost.

     This experiment tells us very little about the topic. I don't think that anyone would be remotely surprised that if you took a working design, and cut an inch and a half off of one wing,  that it wouldn't work and/or need a lot of tipweight. Now, if you had some observations about how it flew once you put in sufficient tip weight, then, that might tell us something.

   The lateral CP of the wing is offset from the geometric centerline of the wing by differential speed effects. However, the "old masters" were off by factors of 3-10 in the amount of differential needed, depending on the design. The right answer, at least to balance the speed differential,  for ~35-sized planes, is on the order of 1/2".  And, the "old masters" completely missed the exact same effect on the tail, resulting in designs like the All-American.


Over the years,  cut-and-try experimentation determined that  we needed for various "warts" on the outboard flap. Now we know why.

     Brett

Steve Fitton

Is the current Infinity using equal panels?
Steve

RandySmith

Quote from: Steve Fitton on July 23, 2006, 09:37:29 PM
Is the current Infinity using equal panels?

Hi Steve
Not speaking for Brett, but i have  tried about adozen differant wing panel lenghts, and  also equal panels. I have found  that  about 3/4 inch to be  perfect  on 59 to 61 inch span planes.

Regards
Randy

Brett Buck

Quote from: Steve Fitton on July 23, 2006, 09:37:29 PM
Is the current Infinity using equal panels?

5/8" on the wing, 0 on the tail. I'm planning to do the offset tail experiment with extensions on the tips and a new outboard flap (same chord as inboard, vice 1/1/8" larger like it is now.

    Brett

Steve Fitton

Thanks Brett and Randy for the comments.  I'd flown equal panels for awhile, and was caught a bit suprise by how much less tipweight you carry on an offset wing like my Avanti I just started fooling with.  I was thinking the Infinity was equal span, although the fact it had offset was probably mentioned ages ago and it never registered.

Steve
Steve

Brett Buck

Quote from: Steve Fitton on July 25, 2006, 09:49:46 PM
Thanks Brett and Randy for the comments.  I'd flown equal panels for awhile, and was caught a bit suprise by how much less tipweight you carry on an offset wing like my Avanti I just started fooling with.

    To first approximation, it really *is* like moving the fuselage over to act as tipweight. Figure the fuselage and all the attached parts are 75% of the weight of the airplane, maybe 45 oz of a 60 oz airplane. 3/4"x45 oz =33.75 in-oz of rolling moment. That's about equivalent to an ounce and a quarter in the tip. This is not exactly rigorous but it's close enough to explain the effect.

   What doing it to excess creates are the *secondary* effects like having the tail offset from the wing, the thrust vector not aimed through the CG, etc.

     Brett

RC Storick

#20
I think of it just like stagger. Stagger is when a race Bike or Car is set up to turn left. The theory of it being like wing tip weight is plausible however "I think it creates more lift" Meaning less tip weight. Everyone who knows my attitude on weight knows that I think thats a good thought.  f~

By the way it's my first post in this section.  %^
AMA 12366

Gordon Tarbell

Make Right rear tire bigger car turns left.
Gordon Tarbell AMA 15019

RandySmith

Quote from: Steve Fitton on July 25, 2006, 09:49:46 PM
Thanks Brett and Randy for the comments.  I'd flown equal panels for awhile, and was caught a bit suprise by how much less tipweight you carry on an offset wing like my Avanti I just started fooling with.  I was thinking the Infinity was equal span, although the fact it had offset was probably mentioned ages ago and it never registered.

Steve

Hi Steve

In the planes I tried with equal  span  I had as much as  2  1/2 ounces  of  tip weight.  Thats  a  lottta  lead.
Everything I have built or have under constrution  use  between  1/2  to  3/4  inch  offset panels.

Brett  I actualy  had  a plane  that used offset in the  stab-elev. was 1/4 inch to be  the  same  as  the  wing? really could tell no  differance. I had  thought about trying  that again  sometime, so it will be  interesting to see  what you  find

Randy

Steve Fitton

Randy,

  Thats about what my equal span Time Machine carries.  2.0 oz lead plus an indeterminate amount of extra in the non-hollowed outer tip.  It almost bit me in the Avanti 50 where I have taken out all but 1/4oz from the weight box but have the again indeterminate amount of weight in the non-hollowed tip.  That 1/4 oz may have to come out as well.  I should have remembered this fact with offset panels but didn't.  Now I know why your plans show the outboard tip hollowed(!)

Steve
Steve

Jim Pollock

Brett, Steve, Ted - All

I understand the effects of wing offset and plan on using 5/8" offset on my
Excelsior.  Another offset that I may try is making the inboard tip of the Stab/elevator 1/16" lower than absolute level to help with gyrscopic precession.  Of course I don't know if that would be sufficient to help or not, but the idea is start with just a little and revise later if needed.  Is anyone else going to try stab tilt?

Jim Pollock   :!


Advertise Here