News:

 

CLICK HERE--><--CLICK HERE

Flap design - Flat surface or contoured to follow the airfoil?

Started by Bill Schluckbier, December 16, 2023, 06:52:13 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Howard Rush

Quote from: Ken Culbertson on April 06, 2024, 09:58:48 AM
For what it is worth, I have been using this method for making recessed flaps and elevators for a couple of years.  Sorry the pictures are a bit fuzzy but here is the method.  Make the elevator with the desired round LE.  This one uses pocket hinges with the pivot at the center of the LE radius.  Sand it to finished shape and wrap it with 100 grit sandpaper.  Use it as a sanding block to carve out the Stab/wing TE to just over the desired depth to make the hinge line match the TE.  Take off the sandpaper and mold a strip of 1/32" balsa around it.  After it dries take the molded piece off and put three layers of blue tape on the stab/flap.  Put the molded 1/32 over the tape and glue it into the stab/wing TE.  Perfect fit, even gap.

Ken

That is cool.
The Jive Combat Team
Making combat and stunt great again

Ken Culbertson

AMA 15382
If it is not broke you are not trying hard enough.
USAF 1968-1974 TAC

doug coursey

Quote from: Bob Hunt on April 07, 2024, 05:23:27 AM
I ran across a photo that somewhat illustrates the point I made above about thicker flap leading edges (top to bottom). This photo shows just how thick (deep?) the trailing edge of the wing on my Wildfire twin is. Naturally the corresponding flap follows the airfoil, and it's leading edge is just as thick or deep.. Again, this makes for a very rigid flap that will not twist when driven from one end is the tendency for a thinner flap.   

Later - Bob Hunt
is that a foam wing or a lost foam version like your tucker
AMA 21449

doug coursey

Quote from: Bob Hunt on April 07, 2024, 05:23:27 AM
I ran across a photo that somewhat illustrates the point I made above about thicker flap leading edges (top to bottom). This photo shows just how thick (deep?) the trailing edge of the wing on my Wildfire twin is. Naturally the corresponding flap follows the airfoil, and it's leading edge is just as thick or deep.. Again, this makes for a very rigid flap that will not twist when driven from one end as is the tendency for a thinner flap.   

Later - Bob Hunt


IS ONE OF THE PLANES YOU USED CARBON MATT AND NITRATE DOPE ON..IF IT IS HOW DOES THE PAINT HOLD UP USING NITRATE AND THEN BUTYRATE OVER IT....DOUG
AMA 21449

Mark wood

Interesting topic. I've got a number of NACA reports where there has been a lot of testing gap, shape and sealing of flaps. In most instances sealing works well at reducing drag but doesn't affect the lift slope or maximum achievable levels very much and often the maximum lift achieved is greater for flaps with a small 0.01C (1% flap chord) gap. I don't think we actually operate in the maximum lift regions which means the differences are not very significant.

I think for models smaller flaps with a plain hinges work just fine and don't have much of an impact on control moments. As for the number of hinges, in the 4/4 arena more than 2 is too many. The problem there is that wing flexes and the surfaces tend to bind under load with more than two hinges. Having said that, my comfort level with models is three because that's what I was taught.

The shape of plain flaps can impact the maximum lift but I'm not entirely convinced that these airplanes push into that zone. My testing with the camera watching the in flight AOA seems to indicate the flapped models is peaking at 6 - 8 degrees AOA which doesn't reach the zone where the maximum Cl is reached. Here my test example is one airplane so there could be others which do. My current project, which I am now back from a summers worth of pulling the camper around the west, is using a deep offset hinge and cove. I posted some videos of some full size flight testing using a similar arrangement. The whole effort is in managing the gap in a manor that improves performance which is actually a tough one to actually define what it is exactly we perceive when flying.

I've had a couple of false starts and hopefully I'm finally on a road to actually completing something. It hasn't been easy as there are a bunch of elements involved. The toughest one is how to make the cove which does the right things easily. I think I've got that finally figured out and I've got the laser cutting files ready.
Life is good AMA 1488
Why do we fly? We are practicing, you might say, what it means to be alive...  -Richard Bach
"Physics is like sex: sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it." – Richard P. Feynman
Take off's are optional. Landings are mandatory, it's only a question of quality.

Matt Colan

Speaking of flaps, I came across this recently on Instagram. It's a Red Bull air race plane of Mike Bragot's. Look at the aileron root and you see a fairing where the aileron is. My guess based on watching the Red Bull air races for a number of years is it's to increase the effectiveness of the aileron to increase roll rate, which means the faster in the roll the fast you get out of the roll and might fly a little faster through the course. Am I on the right track with that?

In our realm I'm not sure there would be much use for these but with all the small aero gizmos sprouting on planes lately including my own, it's a fun thought experiment and maybe worth trying
Matt Colan

Dave_Trible

Matt I'd call that a mini-fence.   My guess is they found the ailerons were not effective enough and these were added (for boundary layer control/wash-off) to make them more effective.   
I'm becoming less interested in sealing the flaps and elevators.   What I dislike most is that when flying in cooler weather ( a nice day here now is in the 50's)  the plastic tape gets pretty stiff and restricts the control throw and 'feel' in ways I don't like.   I prefer very free controls.  If it is 80 degrees fine.  If you were at the Worlds you saw most the airplanes could not use sealed hinges because they were like those described above including all the Sharks.  They did not use coving in general.   I suppose if your flaps are small and/or not deflecting very far a small 'leak' through the hinge line might be more apparent in flight but otherwise I believe that where there is abundant lift generated there isn't enough of an issue to worry about in general.  I'd prefer freely moving controls under all weather conditions.

Dave
AMA 20934
FAA Certificate FA3ATY4T94
Investing in a Gaza resort if the billionaire doesn't take all my social security check

Dave_Trible

AMA 20934
FAA Certificate FA3ATY4T94
Investing in a Gaza resort if the billionaire doesn't take all my social security check

Chuck_Smith

Ruminations of an aerospace engineer with 55 years of flying stunt (controline and full scale) - all IMHO and all alternative viewpoints kindly welcomed:

Up here in the frozen north, as noted by others tape can be a real issue. I've also pulled ships out of mothballs and found the tape had stiffened to the point the ship was no longer flyable, so I avoid it.

The thing that folks (again IMHO) should strive to keep in mind is that air does what it does because it has viscosity and momentum. Because of this, it really doesn't like going around sharp corners. So what I do and it works for me and maybe not for you is that I leave the trailing edge of the wing as sharp as I can keep it, and put a triangular point on the front of the flap. This applies to the elevator/stab joint too. I put recessed notches in the front of the flap for the hinges. And old-school technique but I do focus on keeping the sharp edges. Works well for me, maybe not for you but adding tape to this really didn't seem to make any change. My methodology is that I want to create as many sharp corners as I can that the air needs to pass around because the air's mass and viscosity fight against sharp turns in the airflow. Like I said, works for me, maybe not for you but you may want to consider it.

I will say the worst configuration in my opinion is to round the trailing edge of the wing and the leading edge of the flap.

As far as sealing the gap my experience in full scale experimental aircraft from aerobatics to high performance sailplanes indicates to me that if the gap is sealed the effectiveness of the control isn't noticably changed (say roll rate since pitch is never an issue in full-scale since required pitch response is biologically limited by the pilot's ability to withstand the G forces. ), HOWEVER(!) the stick force required is lowered dramatically. I mean, on some planes it's almost an order of magnitude less. I remember one aerobatic plane that took so much stick force for a full aileron deflection that I was unable to get the stick all the way over. Sealing the gap made it a two-fingers and thumb operation. That much difference!

The perceived difference was that the ailerons were more effective, but the data didn't hold that to be true. Roll rate was virtually unchanged but the control effort was so much less it made the "feel" more effective.  I theorize that this same phenomena holds true with stunt ships, but that's going to be a many beers debate.

I guess my old guy advice is try different things and see what works best for you, because that's really what matters.

All differing points of view welcomed and will be given thoughtful consideration. Heck, I might learn something.

Chuck




AMA 76478

doug coursey

Quote from: Chuck_Smith on November 27, 2024, 10:50:58 AM
Ruminations of an aerospace engineer with 55 years of flying stunt (controline and full scale) - all IMHO and all alternative viewpoints kindly welcomed:

Up here in the frozen north, as noted by others tape can be a real issue. I've also pulled ships out of mothballs and found the tape had stiffened to the point the ship was no longer flyable, so I avoid it.

The thing that folks (again IMHO) should strive to keep in mind is that air does what it does because it has viscosity and momentum. Because of this, it really doesn't like going around sharp corners. So what I do and it works for me and maybe not for you is that I leave the trailing edge of the wing as sharp as I can keep it, and put a triangular point on the front of the flap. This applies to the elevator/stab joint too. I put recessed notches in the front of the flap for the hinges. And old-school technique but I do focus on keeping the sharp edges. Works well for me, maybe not for you but adding tape to this really didn't seem to make any change. My methodology is that I want to create as many sharp corners as I can that the air needs to pass around because the air's mass and viscosity fight against sharp turns in the airflow. Like I said, works for me, maybe not for you but you may want to consider it.

I will say the worst configuration in my opinion is to round the trailing edge of the wing and the leading edge of the flap.

As far as sealing the gap my experience in full scale experimental aircraft from aerobatics to high performance sailplanes indicates to me that if the gap is sealed the effectiveness of the control isn't noticably changed (say roll rate since pitch is never an issue in full-scale since required pitch response is biologically limited by the pilot's ability to withstand the G forces. ), HOWEVER(!) the stick force required is lowered dramatically. I mean, on some planes it's almost an order of magnitude less. I remember one aerobatic plane that took so much stick force for a full aileron deflection that I was unable to get the stick all the way over. Sealing the gap made it a two-fingers and thumb operation. That much difference!

The perceived difference was that the ailerons were more effective, but the data didn't hold that to be true. Roll rate was virtually unchanged but the control effort was so much less it made the "feel" more effective.  I theorize that this same phenomena holds true with stunt ships, but that's going to be a many beers debate.

I guess my old guy advice is try different things and see what works best for you, because that's really what matters.

All differing points of view welcomed and will be given thoughtful consideration. Heck, I might learn something.

Chuck
i had an experience with an RC 4 point racing hydroplane. it was built with the sponsons having rounded edges on the bottom  and would not get up on plane,we couldnt figure out why and another guy told us it was because of the rounded edges  we redid the edges and made them sharp and it fixed the problem. air does the same thing as water and follows the round edges causing drag instead of flowing off without drag...i build my planes with sharp edges on all the trailing edges also so sealing the gaps is not necessary......
AMA 21449

Chuck_Smith

And as we say in the aerospace business, the best part is NO part.

And rereading my earlier post, when I say sharp trailing edge on wing I mean it is cut off perpendicular to the chord line, not pointed. The flap is pointed at the LE. Nothing revolutionary, it's an old-school trick visible on many plans.
AMA 76478



Advertise Here