stunthanger.com
Speed,Combat,Scale,Racing => Speed Talk => Topic started by: Paul Smith on February 29, 2016, 01:35:54 PM
-
My entry form arrived last Friday. I'm sending in my entry today.
We've had months of discussion about what is a modified Fox 35 Stunt. After due consideration, here's how I plan to run the event.
A modified Fox 35 Stunt is an engine that looks like a Fox 35 Stunt from the outside. That is to say the crankcase and head look like Fox 35 Stunt products. I will not look inside the engine.
A FORA or a K&B or a Nelson with a Fox logo attached does not look like a Fox 35 Stunt to me.
-
I just love this hobby
-
well there go's my JETT pylon engine
-
Don't worry. You can still use it in Saint Louis.
-
Good plan Paul
-
The JETT Pylon Engine with a Fox 35 decal would be allowed in St Louis either
Bottom line - the crankcase of the engine has to be Fox 35 Stunt engine with the plain bearing
Fred
-
here's a thought Paul.
You could have a prize for the most creative Fox .35 at the contest.........
~if it ain't fun, I ain't doin it~
-
(and head look like Fox 35 Stunt products)
Paul, I think you need to clarify this a little. There are a lots of aftermarket bolt on parts made for the Fox 35 Stunt like the Hemi head, Smith head and Fox high compression free flight head, plus a few more. Also, all the older Fox 35 Rocket, 35X, 36X heads will bolt up to the Stunt case too. My suggestion would be to allow any head because of all the options that are available and it's easier to police.
-
If the engine has an original Fox 35 stunt crankcase, runs on suction and has the original plain bushed front bearing then that should be only inspection required.
We have not turned anyone away if they have the stuffer back plates, hemi-heads or different needle valves. In fact very few that we have seen are flying with the original Fox needle valves.
Fred
-
should get extra points if using a Fox needle valve assbly n~
-
(should get extra points if using a Fox needle valve assbly)
Would using it as a wing tip skid count?
-
Can I use a fox 35 as wing tip weight and power it with a Nelson?
-
You are welcome to change the backplate, glow plug, NVA, bolts prop nut. Just use the Fox 35 Stunt crankcase & head.
If you are good enough to make a new piston, sleeve, rod, and crankshaft, you can rework the head from the inside.
If everyone who entered this discussion enters the contest the event will be a HUGE success.
-
I want pictures.....all this gives new meaning to "lipstick on a pig"
-
Here you go
-
looks more like my perky LL~
-
Maybe can have a "disallowed modified Fox 35 Stunt" class. No prize, just recognition.
-
yah.....make it a "Big Daddy Roth Fox" Best monster award......
Put the fun into the event....I think this link has inspired more speed merchants than anything our AMA or special interest group has done in awhile.
~^
-
The rib blanks are the first step towards my Fox 35 plane. I had to settle for re-habed Perky in lieu of a new one to make a Fox plane.
-
LOL, another rule change, how many are scraping their billet heads right now?
MM
-
The information on the Brodak website says the contest will use St Louis Fox 35 rules. The St Louis Fox 35 rules allow for Hemi Heads so be careful on making rule changes on this forum. Any rules changes for a sanctioned contest need to be advertised to everyone thru the official sanction on the AMA calendar. These are basic guidelines that all CD's must follow.
There will be people showing up with non-stock Fox 35 heads that may not have read this forum
Fred
-
i know of two
-
Must not forget "secret rules"
-
I would like to take a poll from all competitors and non-competitors on their opinion of whether this engine meets the St Louis Fox 35 speed rules, which will be used at Brodak.
Al
-
looks good to me ,, Fox combat special slant plug head
-
if it looks like a skunk..... LL~
-
Here's one of my 35 racers with an old 36 plain bearing cyl & liner with the slant plug head cut down in diameter. Runs better in the fox stunt case that in the old shiny 36/29 case.
legal or not?
-
looks good,have u flown it yet??
-
Not yet I have three to do some testing on and waiting for the white stuff to go away.
This picture was taken three days ago, notice the white crap on the porch.
Looks like this week end might be some flying weather as the snow is almost gone now.
-
Use a Fox 35 Stunt crankcase and head.
Modify them all you want.
An entirely different head is not a modified head.
Vent the tank to the atmosphere.
Have fun.
-
i would like to see combat special and the Hemi head aloud , both fox parts
-
I agree with the open head idea. It's not too difficult to figure a clamp button system though
-
Paul, Did you get the PM I sent a week or so ago? TS
-
Well here is a baffle combat head and a stock 35 stunt head used as a clamp.
Looks legal to me.
I don't think i would worry to much about cylinder heads as Smith will be over turned by the masses at Brodak ,and it also states on Brodaks site that St Louis rules are what are being used so Paul has stepped on his foot by trying to change them because he don't have a hemi head for his motor.
All he is doing is killing a fun event by making foolish rule changes
-
I think helmets should be required.
(see Brodak combat thread) #^
-
here is the completed head for my Fox speed. A bit of work but I have great expectations.
-
Going to need a lot of shims to clear the baffle LL~
-
Baffle isn't needed in this one. It is a little hard to start though, I set the ports at 66 deg....I think that's right. Anyway, I'll use this stuff if it remains balky.
-
OK Ken, I'll bite. What are you using for a piston and liner?
-
OK Ken, I'll bite. What are you using for a piston and liner?
Nobody need ever know. The INSIDE of the engine is the free fire zone.
-
Hello Paul,
Well! This evolved FAST from me
entering my good Fox .35 Stunt on a small
airframe, to me dragging out boxes of 1960's
speed equipment and old combat engines
that I "inherited".
Some interesting Fox stuff that I've never really
considered.
So, I went on Brodak's site and read the rules.
I can't find the "St. Louis rules". Can anyone
guide me to a link?
Also it says 60 foot 0.016 lines. Is that right?
Not 0.015?
I know I can't use monoline or pressure,
but can I use....
A dolly?
A speed pan?
On board glow driver?
Asymmetrical wing?
A chamber?
I probably couldn't get
a pipe to work well in a short
time. I built a lot of pipes for
my race bikes back in the day,
so I might try if it's legal.
I'd like to adapt some of this old
speed stuff if I can to save time.
Cheers! - K.
OOps! Just found the St. Louis rules.
Yikes!
Please forgive my previous babbling.
Fox 35 Speed rules
This event is to encourage anyone with an
airplane with a Fox 35 STUNT
engine to get involved in an entry level speed event.
1.
The only engine for this event is a Fox 35 stunt engine,
NO Fox 35 Combat motors, engine must run on suction,
No pressure fuel systems, engine can be modified ,
but must remain plain bearing for the crankshaft.
Needle valve can be changed.
2.
Model may be either a full fuselage or profile,
suggestions include:
Skyray,
Flitestreak,
Ringmaster,
or similar models.
3.
Minimum
one (1) wheel, plane must ROG,
any dia
. No dollies!
4.
Spinner okay or acorn prop nut.
5.
Commercially
available propellers only.
6.
The flying wires shall be 60 feet in length
as measured from the center of the fuselage to
the center of the control handle Only
2 wire control systems allowed,
no monolines.
7.
The flying wires are to
be .016 solid steel music wire.
8.
Pull test of 16 g’s shall be applied to
the model, flying wires, handle
, and safety thong
prior to each attempt.
9.
Model will
be timed for 1 mile,
14 laps from point of release.
10.
Pilot is not required to use the AMA speed pylon.
11.
Contestant will be given
four (4) attempts to complete three (3)
official flights.
12.
Awards are to be for 1st, 2nd, 3rd
and best average speed.
13.
All other safety rules in the AMA rule book apply.
14.
Fuel will be provided per AMA Rules
-
St Louis Fox 35 speed rules
https://lafayetteesquadrillecl.files.wordpress.com/2014/08/fox-35-speed-rules-rev-a.pdf
-
Thanks Fred,
The only problem
will be finding 0.016
solid lines.
Cheers! - K.
-
You got the rules right....any airplane can be used, but it must have at least one wheel. If I could make a Cox PT-19 stay together for 14 laps with a Fox 35 in the nose I would fly it...but I scratch built my own airplane.
Good luck!
Fred
-
I ordered my lines from Melvin in Kansas...
http://www.mbsmodelsupply.com/Catalog.pdf
Here is my video on how to wrap the solid lines....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nk-7_3i2Kos
Fred
-
Hopefully someone does this at the Brodak contest, but we always have a set of lines available to use if a pilot does not have a set of solid lines. John Moll and myself can make our flying lines available at the St Louis contests if a pilot did not have a set of .016 dia solid lines.
Multiple pilots have told me they don't want to or can't be bothered to make a set of lines for the contest so when we offer to use our lines it makes it easy for them to enter the contest. Making the lines can be a pain so I understand that, that is why we make our personal set of flying lines available for anyone who needs it.
Fred
-
Hello and thanks again Fred,
I'm here reading down the past
posts about Fox Speed, so I'm
learning a lot.
My mistake looking on the Brodak
site for complete rules.
I'm not sure if I understood
what Paul is saying.
Are 0.018 stranded allowed?
-
The information posted on the Brodak website says they are going to use St Louis Fox 35 speed rules, so having said that, they really should have a link to the rules on our club website but they don't.
Because the Brodak website says they are going to use St Louis Fox 35 speed rules the only lines that are legal are the .016 solids. Because this is a speed event the solid lines need to be used. The Brodak CD would need to revise the sanction to allow .018 braided lines since they have already advertised that the St Louis rules will be used. Once you have advertised one set of rules you can't change the rules on the fly, other pilots would have a legal protest if rules are changed on the fly.
Fred
-
I see that John Moll and Bill Hughes (well respected guys) are NOT using the fox 35 stunt head on their entries at the Ice-O-Lated contest this year. So if they came to Brodak to compete they would be DISQUALIFIED as per what Paul Smith wrote earlier. I do not agree with him on this. I'm writing this because I think Brodak should be in sync with the rest of the country that is using the St Louis Fox 35 speed rules.
Opinions please.
Al
-
I would agree, the Brodak website says they will be using the St Louis rules so that means they can not make any changes. If they do not agree with the St Louis rules then they need to write their own rules but that means changing the AMA sanction that says they will be using the St Louis rules. If you look on the AMA website it also says the Brodak fly-in will be using the St Louis rules.
You are right, John, Bill and myself would all be told that are engines do not meet the rules they are using, If I was there I would protest to the CD and claim that the sanction says that they are using the St Louis rules and those same rules allow for the HEMI heads. Hate to put on my lawyer hat but as a CD myself you have to live to the rules that you have advertised on the AMA sanction and you can not make any changes on the fly.
Fred
-
I have been following this closely as I've been considering competing. I interpret the rules as the only thing that needs to be stock is the case.
Swap out piston,liner, head, crank, bushing,needle valve, back plate , titanium thrust washer, etc.
-
that is right, the case and the plain bearing need to be stock, other than that the needle valve, head, back plate, piston and liner can all be different. The only inspection John Moll does or any other CD is four things. We provide the fuel at our contests.
1) Using suction (no pressure systems)
2) Plain Bearing, Fox 35 Stunt engine
3) any airplane, but must have at least one wheel
4) .016 solid lines, 60 feet long
We had all sorts of combinations at the Ice-O-Lated contest but they all used suction fuel system with a Fox 35 stunt engine, plain bearing. This is really a fun event because you are not restricted to a lot of specific rules. I love the fact that everybody's airplane are all different.
Hope this helps
Fred
-
I wanna go just to watch the hissy fits...... LL~
-
Ken
Brother I am with you... I thought the rules were pretty well described and this thread has me thinking this one event will actually get into fist fights...considering how many are so fixated on everything
Commercially available props.... if I make a prop that gets 5 MPH better and offer it for sale only in Latvia, San Salvador, and Taiwan would this be allowed?
-
I hear ya Fred. I suppose that ZZ Prop and Wilks would be considered commercial. On the other hand, there are smaller cottage shops that sell props and I buy them, so I guess that means you cannot maker yourself that isn't sold.
The intent is something you can buy in a hobby shop, but today, our hobby shops are on line sites. The one and only hobby shop in this town has nothing I can use. Can you modify a "stock prop" ?
I had no idea St Louie was so complicated
-
Ken and I are having fun....who would have thought such a fun and fairly simple event could get so mind blowingly complicated
You know you can take a Fox case...put a new bushing in it and then grove the ID for an O ring front and rear, then micro polish the crank ( grits up to 20,000 in the diamond paste world for Boy Scout axle polishing) ) for a very close finish and fit.... fill the area between the O rings with pure moly beads and get an extra 550 RPM
Do NOT forget my earlier suggestion of High Performance coatings... the ceramic piston dome and slippery skirting made a very significant difference on my 80 CI Harley engine
-
I would like to take a poll from all competitors and non-competitors on their opinion of whether this engine meets the St Louis Fox 35 speed rules, which will be used at Brodak.
Al
Yes Al, I agree your motor complies!
Tom
-
To be honest you are making this too complicated, buy a prop at the hobby shop or thru an on-line source that is available to everybody, and use a Fox 35 Stunt. The event is really simple I have no idea how it got so complicated on this forum.
A fox 35 stunt is a basic engine and really don't over think this, replace the head, back plate, needle valve and have some fun. Build an airplane, grab any airplane and fly it with a set of 60' solid lines. Our technical inspection here in St Louis lasts about 15 seconds and is a casual glance at the engine and lines.
As you can see by the last web page I posted on our club website there is a wide variety of models being flown. Most people are using the APC props.
If a CL scale guy who knows nothing about Speed can scratch build and fly in this event, it means it's as simple as it gets. I built the model without any plans put a Fox 35 on the nose and flew it. I had to get use to the fact that I didn't have a throttle to land under power!
Fred
-
I just got around (due to decent weather) to running the latest mods on my Geezer-speed engine (la .25) N.W.B Proto. it did well and because it's comparable to a good Fox stunt....I thought I would pass this along. I used a Hobby Lobby standard short plug will no side effects. It ran as well as the K&B, McCoy plug I also used. Peaked out at 20,500 so that was a nice bennie. The plugs are inexpensive and I will go get s'more!
K
-
Ken, what prop did you use for that 20K?
-
the prop is a bench prop that is a Kelley 6 x 6.5. Martin Higgs and I have been making mods and comparing rpm with this prop.
It's right at expectations with the mods and bench prop. Wish I could turn the Whitney prop at that RPM.
-
Ken, bolt that Fox you were showing off on a plane and send it to "The Brodak Shoot Out" along with Charlie Johnson, to see if it can keep pace with the heavy hitters y1
Al
-
The identity of the heavy hitters will be revealed on June 15th.
This far, just big talkers.
-
Ken, bolt that Fox you were showing off on a plane and send it to "The Brodak Shoot Out" along with Charlie Johnson, to see if it can keep pace with the heavy hitters y1
Al
Al, I just showed the head chamber. I'd much rather use one of my la .25's but that's no fun. I don't really think I can make the contest, but think it's going to be one fun event. I've seen one of the heavy hitters and have already surrendered.
K
-
(I've seen one of the heavy hitters and have already surrendered)
I don't think so Ken. He is coming with strong entries in Fox Speed & Perky for the Brodak Shoot Out, its going to AWESOME.
Al
-
you're spot on Al...this should be the better speed shoot out of the year. I'm having enough trouble getting my G-Speed engines sorted out (LA .25) Been testing all week and Marty Higgs "Frankenstein 2" has so far come to the top bench speeds. on 10% / 20% oil 50 syn, 50 caster.
APC 8 x 6 ........18,150 rpm
Bench prop.......21,700 rpm.
If it can be done with one of these slugs, it can be done with a Fox .35 stunt.
K
-
HE WHO ???
-
This will be fun if half the people show up that posted. I have a Goldberg Shoestring that will do about 60+mph.
-
Fred, a simple event gets complicated because someone is faster than me so I want to carefully go over the rules to see if there's any advantage I can take. So, there is the black letter which is tangible and there is common sense which varies.
Common sense says an engine is an engine because of it's crankcase but nowhere does it say you have to use the fox 35 crankcase it only has to be a plain bearing shaft. The rules say no combat engines but people are using combat engine parts, how many parts are you allowed? Common sense would say everything but the combat crankcase.
Also, it says only commercially available props. Common sense says no carbon fiber props but there have been many carbon fiber props commercially available for many years including APC.
It's just verbiage that can easily be fixed with a small re-write of the rules to close a few loop holes.
And to anyone that says I don't have skin in the game:
(http://i889.photobucket.com/albums/ac93/giffy6/100_0401.jpg) (http://s889.photobucket.com/user/giffy6/media/100_0401.jpg.html)
MM
-
I am not sure how this one rule can get any easier, the motor must be a Fox 35 stunt.
The parts attached to the basic Fox 35 stunt engine can be modified per the rules so you can take advantage of that and so has everyone else. I put a hemi-head on and used a different needle valve. If anyone has used a different crank, piston or liner we have way of knowing, but the basic engine started out as a Fox 35 stunt with the plain bearing. The rules state that a Fox 35 combat motor can be used so that eliminates that engine crankcase.
1. The only engine for this event is a Fox 35 stunt engine, NO Fox 35 Combat motors, engine must run on suction, No pressure fuel systems, engine can be modified , but must remain plain bearing for the crankshaft. Needle valve can be changed.
Fred
-
Fred, brother you need to edit your post... you missed "no" an a "cannot"
I know what you mean but it is confusing
-
I'm sorry Fred but I'm still not getting this.
You say - " the motor must be a Fox 35 stunt."
Then you say - "The rules state that a Fox 35 combat motor can be used"
Huh?
-
the rules say "NO fox 35 combat motors", in other words the Fox 35 combat motors cannot be used per the St Louis rules. When John Moll wrote the rules he put that in to make sure the Fox 35 Combat motors were not included on the list. Only the Fox 35 stunt was listed.
Fred
-
i dont see how it could be any simpler. buy a Fox 35 Stunt case, leave it a bushing case and build an engine, put it in a Quiki Rat and go for it.
-
is the word "sandbagging" supposed to be hyphenated?
-
Giffy, Lookin' good! See you in Middlesex in June. TS
-
Raising The STAKES ;D
-
I was able to bore my case 30 over and put my Rossi 65 P&L in her. RPM hasn't changed but I'm swinging a 9x12 Grish! VD~
Tom
-
after looking ,looks like it left the case very thin, so am going with a Nelson pylon 40 AAC P/S. my need to try and make a rod to hook everything together
-
"Gather round cats, and I'll tell you a story
bout how to become an all American boy"........
-
Ken that's awesome. I was thinking of doing something like that but wasn't sure I should take it to that level. Is that a SuperTiger G21/35 rear valve crank? You must have ground the crank web down allot to get it to center on the cylinder bore. Nice work, what is the rpm on an APC 8-8 pylon prop?
MM
-
If anyone has used a different crank, piston or liner we have a way of knowing
Fred
that is right, the case and the plain bearing need to be stock,
It doesn't say in the rules the crankcase and the bearing need to be stock just that you have to use them.
Are there rules that aren't written down? What do you mean by "If anyone has used a different crank, piston or liner we have a way of knowing", was the intent to use ALL the Fox 35 stunt parts??
There are allot of guys fired up right now all with machine shops doing wonderful crazy things to this engine. Modified engines, that was intent right?
MM
-
once again, this was sent to me via a 3rd party mail....no idea who the builder is. VD~
-
Ballpark, how fast do you have to be in the air to get a 105mph result from a standing start?
MM
-
This engine isn't mine. I keep getting pictures from a 3rd party email ......whoever is making this thing is up to something fo-sho.
Ken
-
Ballpark, how fast do you have to be in the air to get a 105mph result from a standing start?
MM
110mph
-
In the early days of 36 Profile Carrier a good estimate was one second (or less) added to the running high speed time.
Thus, if it actually does 19 (95 MPH) in the air it will do 20 (90 MPH) off the line. What Al said.
Better for a light plane, A LOT worse for a heavy plane.
My Clown racers flown as Clown speed also only lose about 5 MPH off the line.
-
ready to go
-
Nice, I like the name. How big did you make the tank?
MM
-
tank is a 1 oz coffin tank
-
I'm ready for a test flight ;D
Al
-
Love the retro look!
This is some shoot out
-
Ready to rock in south Jersey.
(http://i889.photobucket.com/albums/ac93/giffy6/100_0444.jpg) (http://s889.photobucket.com/user/giffy6/media/100_0444.jpg.html)
MM