stunthanger.com

Speed,Combat,Scale,Racing => Scale Models => Topic started by: Paul Smith on June 16, 2012, 04:51:46 AM

Title: Scientific Beechcraft Staggerwing from the 2011 Brodak to the 2012
Post by: Paul Smith on June 16, 2012, 04:51:46 AM
Mission accomplished!  I got it as a botched, and barely-started assembly job last year and flew it this year. It's about 80% the actual 1949 kit and 20% replacement parts. There was some alteration and revision to make it like Mrs Olive Beech's personal ride.

The paint masks were contributed by Charles (Avaiojet) of this forum. It employs a Joe Just stacked Fox bellcrank won in his carrier postal. The single test flight and two officials all went off perfectly with no adjustment needed.

That's John Brodak and Jack Sheeks at the static judging and some of the heavyweight (12-to-18 pound) competition.

I  believe that's Ed Mason getting his whole body in action vs the C-124.
Title: Re: Scientific Beechcraft Staggerwing from the 2011 Brodak to the 2012
Post by: john e. holliday on June 16, 2012, 07:52:38 AM
I guess you were happy with the little plane.   How did you score overall? H^^
Title: Re: Scientific Beechcraft Staggerwing from the 2011 Brodak to the 2012
Post by: Paul Smith on June 17, 2012, 06:39:09 AM
There was a "front pack" of big planes (10-to-18 pounders) that had me by 14 static points.  
(This is a revision: after closer review it was found that the scorekeeper had transposed some of the static & flight scores on the big board, but the totals and order of finish were OK).

I was in a close third-or-fourth place battle, which I pulled out with a really good second flight.  

After round one it was obvious that 1-2 and 3-4 could be flipped with a good second effort.  The guys went to the max and ultimately both the C-124 and the AT-6 overextended themselves and took some damage.  

My two-pounder only gave up 4 flight points vs first & second place.  The landing gear is totally rigid and most of the lost points were due to "clatterly" landings.  Also, my high flight is a bit marginal, but I'm not alone,
Title: Re: Scientific Beechcraft Staggerwing from the 2011 Brodak to the 2012
Post by: Dennis Adamisin on June 18, 2012, 07:02:39 PM
WTG Paul!

So can you narrow the gap on those 22 static points?
Title: Re: Scientific Beechcraft Staggerwing from the 2011 Brodak to the 2012
Post by: Paul Smith on June 18, 2012, 08:12:00 PM
I should be able to do some with rigging and details.  Probably not all.  The big guys did a lot of work to earn their points.

I was able to get back 6 points just by checking the math.  Now it's only 14.  The totals were OK.  Some of the numbers were flipped when they copied them onto the big board.

I now have five fully flyable CL biplanes.

I might be better off using the Beech for fun scale.  I expect to get most of the 10 scale points in that event.  It was sort of a lark to take one crack at The Big One.
Title: Re: Scientific Beechcraft Staggerwing from the 2011 Brodak to the 2012
Post by: john vlna on June 18, 2012, 08:46:09 PM
It is hard for a small plane to compete in sport scale, the big ones are a better canvass for the detail judges love, but your Beechcraft flies very well for its size, quite impressive overall.
Title: Re: Scientific Beechcraft Staggerwing from the 2011 Brodak to the 2012
Post by: Paul Smith on June 19, 2012, 04:41:24 AM
Thank you very much.

I want to compliment the judges for giving me a fair shake.  There's nothing in the rules that says "big is better" and they gave all the models what they earned regardless of size.

As you say, you can put a lot more detail into an 7-foot model than a 2-footer.  In addition to the time and money to build the thing and the race car trailer to haul it, a big model has a lot more opportunity to make mistakes that lead to downgrades.  On the upside, a big plane gives the fine craftsman more opportunity to excel.

Another observation:  In Sport Scale there's no "complexity bonus", but all the top models were either multiengine or biplanes.  No Piper Cubs here.

On the other hand, Profile was very closely fought battle among single engine fighters of equal size and power.  LA-5, Bearcat, Mig-3, and Corsair, all high and close static points, duking it out in the air.