Sparky,
I'm with you 2 out of 5, at least.
BillyWerwage, f'r sure.
Keith Trostle, absolutely!
Randy Smith, most likely, but he hasn't had the several decades of contribution, yet, that Billy and Keith have.
Bill Noyes is a bit too local, California, to sell to the rest of the country just yet. Qualified in what he is and does, sure, but the regionalism hurts. Moreso when some of us feel an East v. West thing.
Bernie Ash may have been a local hero and guru, but most of us only know him from the Airon and Supersonic. And, the Airon only appeared in the half-page sketch that is repeated in the current SN.
PAMPA has a procedure for nominating/suggesting HoF choices. You make a good start on showing a groundswell for nice prospects!