I'm just having a hard time wrapping my head around all that work on a thin paper covering. I'd be afraid of it being easily damaged.
MM
Well actually medium weight silkspan with about 15 total coats of dope etc is pretty tough. No it's not as puncture resistant as monokote but it's much more durable in terms of heat and sunlight. Monokote coverings deteriorate very quickly and if not carefully protected, look years old after only a month or two of heavy use. Especially the trim looks tacky very quickly.
Polyspan is pretty tough stuff and has puncture restance many times that of silkspan and actually rivals monokote and doesn't peel off after a hundred or so flights. Painted trim on silkspan or polyspan is permanent and doesn't need to be replaced every year like heavily used trim on monokote.
Both types of covering have their uses and draw backs but for the best finish in competition or just pride of worksmanship nothing beats a silkspan, or polyspan and dope finish with an auto clearcoat like two part polyurethane or dupont chroma clear.
If you're a sport flier that wants to get in the air quickly and have an easily repairable finish then nothing beats the film coverings. Excellent for practice airplanes also.
Randy Cuberly