My holder doesn't rock because I hold the whole thing in my left hand so it's clamped down but I can still slide it with my fingers.
I actually like my Prather gage since I got one of the sliders that actually fits from Jim Lee. I also do the hold the whole thing in one hand and manipulate with the fingers so the fight hand can keep the indicator in place and firmly against the prop. I use it a lot.
I'm not sure how accurate they are in terms of absolute value but it really doesn't matter as long as it's consistent and repeatable. They really should be used just as a reference for modifying a prop for more or less pitch at various stations. This whole thing is trial and error. While it's true that having a starting point is handy in getting things to work there are too many variables to really expect find a solution to all the problems associated with the airplane, engine (or motor), and prop in one setup. It's definitely what is referred to as a "Many Body Problem".
I'm not sure anyone knows what the real value in terms of pitch is with an under cambered prop, for instance, is anyway, and a lot of the props I find I'm using these days are just that!
Anyway I think the Prather works well enough for our general purposes of comparison!
Randy Cuberly