ANY plastic spinner with a plastic backplate is not very satisfactory, IMO. 1) The backplate is so thick that there is little if any prop shaft left for the prop nut. 2) They tend to slip and throw the prop or cause you to take an attempt on an official. 3) They're heavy...which might be a good thing, but heavy AND rotating isn't ideal.
The plastic cone/aluminum backplate spinners are pretty hard to beat, but don't come in 3 blade form. Mike Haverly used the backplate and drilled/tapped a couple more holes (changed all to 4-40 SHCS while at it) to fit a plastic cone from a Dubro (I think) plastic spinner for his two Jack Sheeks "Freedom 45" Classics.
Though I don't really like the looks of the typical aluminum spinners with the single screw in the nose, that's what I generally use. I think it would be possible to make a pointy spinner tip with a bit of machining on the tip of the cone, some all-thread, and JB Weld....but I haven't done it. I have re-machined spinner cones, backplates and such. Cones are kinda sketchy, but I machined a chunk of aluminum to nest on the lip and glued the cone on with Bondo, did the mods and heat gunned to remove. We used real Bondo in the machine shop at Boeing for doing this sort of stuff, but could use a lot more Bondo. Bondo is barely strong enough, so I'd suggest something stronger...epoxy & micro balloons or maybe even JB Weld. Heat will loosen the epoxy ok. Even CA could work.

Steve