Mr. Brodak owns many of the businesses in his area, including beer, liqueur, food, Dollar Stores, a trailer park, a drive-in theater, etc.
I'm sure he employs numerous people. It's quite possible that one bad employee used your credit information.
Several years ago I bought a pair of gym shoes at major national sports store in Lansing, Michigan. A $30 deal turned into $2,500 worth of audio/video equipment overnight. Of course I recovered the charges. Bottom line: one bad employee in an otherwise good business.