Three years ago I hosted a CL fun fly here in Salina. The turnout was small, the wind was nasty, but we had fun. I decided on a fun fly vs a contest because I didn't want to try to find judges and wasn't sure what kind of crowd we'd draw. I figured if there was sufficient interest, I could wrangle some judges and file all the appropriate paper work to host a contest the next year. Since the fun fly was lightly attended, I debated even doing a fun fly the second year. We went ahead with a second fun fly, and again the weather was terrible, and we only drew a small crowd, again I debated doing another year. This year the interest was about the same as usual, and the forecast was terrible (rain storms), but the day of the fun fly the clouds parted and the weather was beautiful. We had a few different flyers attend, still a small crowd, but it was a success as those who attended enjoyed themselves. If I'd given up after the first year, we'd have missed out on the fun had the second and third year.
As much as I would love to host a real contest, and draw a large crowd, I know it would take a lot of work, and it probably would draw the same half dozen flyers the fun fly draws. Without knowing for certain that it'd be more successful, I'm hesitant to put in the work myself and ask others to donate their time. I commend you for making the effort to pull a contest together, and I would hope you wouldn't let a bad year discourage you. If you keep at it, maybe the word will spread, the perfect weather will fall on the date, and it'll be the contest you'd hoped for.