Hi Bob,
Could it be that the source of your confusion is that the data-logger reports "% Power"?
That's what the label says, but it's not really power: it's % battery voltage (or duty-cycle for those that care).
You can run very different powers with the same percentage of battery voltage, you simply add more prop load.
Yes, electric motors make more power the harder you load them ... until they over-current and melt. This is backwards of what you have always known.
You kept adding prop load and lowering the RPM as needed, but the power going to the prop probably increased with each prop change you described, even though the datalogger says it used less voltage.
Now, if you were to compare the battery capacity used for each prop, and the peak amps in a climb, you'd see that the largest capacity used and the highest peak amps in a climb all translate to line tension and control authority when and where it counts.
Hope that helps,
Dean