I think what Peter is proposing is something that we have discussed before on the F2B sub committee, and that is the use of remote throttle control in stunt. The AMA rules allowed this previously and Windy Urtnowski used it with some success. The F2B rules do not allow this. I do not personally think that this will be less complicated that what we have now with IC or electric power. Right now the off-the-shelf electric stuff is virtually plug n' play. Pro-stunt engines from Randy Smith and others were the same, BUT still take some intelligent (maybe not the right word) user to get them to work. We always hear...."just do what the top fliers do....build one of their designs.......use the engines they use" etc. Now, you can buy most of the really good designs in kit form, even some in ARF form, and just add one of their chosen power packages. This should mean that the top guys should have been knocked off their respective perches by now. True story?? No ways! The same top fliers are still there with a little shuffling of positions. It all comes down to who is wiggling the handle and it's a total package. Great airplane, power package, coach, correct practice methods, dedication etc. etc. etc. It's quite amazing how no matter what technology comes along, the same guys seem to be able to make the absolute best of it. They all have one common ingredient that cannot be explained rationally or in technical terms, and that is feeling and passion for the sport. They are all like fine musicians playing on the very best instruments. Anyone with enough money can buy a Steinway 9 foot grand piano, but only those with feeling and passion can get the best out of it. So it isn't just the technology, and to answer Peter's question about the throttle, sure we can easily do this.....all you have to do is to get enough votes from the international F2B folks to agree. I think that I will stick to my technical stuff rather than try that one. (we've tried that one before haven't we Peter??)
On Tim's CL esc thing, we have spoken about this in an e-mail a while back. I also have a good friend that is a design engineer with a specialty in motor controls. He has offered me a design, but costing it out has shown that it will be pricey and you need to offer at least a few different sizes. The small quantities will make production really expensive, so for now I will stick to my simple external governor thing and low cost Chinese esc's. I will however play with the idea just to get myself thrown into the deep-end on how these esc's work and for sure, it will improve my programming skills.
Keith R