stunthanger.com

Design => Engineering board => Topic started by: Peter Nevai on June 10, 2011, 06:31:45 PM

Title: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Peter Nevai on June 10, 2011, 06:31:45 PM
Not CL related, yet a engineering challange none the less.
Design a product, that can convey communications on any available media, with excellent performance charachteristics. It has to be compact, durable, and simple to operate. Be able to function unhindered and equally well in the vacum of space and the extreme pressures underwater in the deepest ocean. The retail cost of the device must be affordable to any average person.

Oh it must have built in redundancy

Ok have at it, this should be revealing.
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Gary James on June 10, 2011, 10:55:40 PM
A pencil
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Peter Nevai on June 10, 2011, 11:30:58 PM
A pencil


Give the man a cigar, you would not believe how many engineers Ive run this by, that went into some complicated solutions. Yup, writes underwater, and in space, is lightweight, and compact, it is fully redundant, as if the point breaks, just about all you have to do to get it to work again is chip away some of the wood, and can be had for under a buck. The grease pencil answer would have worked as well.

The pen deserves honerable mention, except a pen has no redundancy.
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: PJ Rowland on June 11, 2011, 02:55:49 AM
During the development of the space program

One Nation Spent Millions of dollars to develop a pen that wrote in Zero gravity - Another Nation used a Pencil.

This is an old (sic) Urban legend.

Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: rustler on June 11, 2011, 03:18:43 PM
I don't understand.

"...on any available media," - How does a pencil convey communications on e.g. the internet? Radio/Television? Telephone?
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: jim gilmore on June 11, 2011, 04:05:18 PM
Personally I was gonna suggest just a finger....
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Chris Wilson on June 15, 2011, 07:38:15 PM
I don't understand.

"...on any available media," - How does a pencil convey communications on e.g. the internet? Radio/Television? Telephone?
Should be  -
"...on any available medium," as defined by "A trade name for printing and writing paper of certain sizes. See Paper."
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Douglas Ames on June 29, 2011, 05:15:46 PM
A Pet Rock...  LL~
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Brett Buck on July 20, 2011, 11:43:44 PM
Another Nation used a Pencil.

   No they didn't - too likely to get grit in the works. And the Fisher space pen was developed on company money.

    Brett
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: PJ Rowland on July 21, 2011, 04:00:19 AM
There was no facts to my quote..

I did mention under that it was an Urban Legend. - I have no idea who used what In space.
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Allan Perret on July 27, 2011, 06:04:11 AM
"convey communications"   ?  

You must be an engineer, I would have just said "communicate"

  LL~
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Larry Cunningham on September 22, 2011, 07:29:20 PM
I would have just said "write"..

And I AM an engineer. ;->

However, I was thinking of a combination blue tooth/USB/wifi/3G iPencil (tm) tablet, with pull out retracting window shade transparent hi-res display and tear off Post-It note paper roll (in 4 popular colors), clickable select waterproof/erasable pens in black/blue/red/orange/yellow or graphite based pencil in shades 4H through 1B, plus microphone, speaker, camera, toothbrush/shaver/mustache and eyebrow trimmer/comb, awl, can opener, saw, pliers, LED flashlight, scissors, knife blade, ivory toothpick, hypo-allergenic key chain and ring, leather-looking fob with optional NASA/BMW/Porsche/Ford badge.. (can be used as a flotation device) Includes charger: 100/115/240V 50/60/400Hz AC : 2 or 3 phase (Wye or Delta wired) or 1.5/5/6/12/28/100VDC with cigarette light plug-in. (LiPo batteries and 8 TB flash memory chip optional.)

..so you won't forget, order before midnight tonight!

L.

"Either do as your neighbors do, or move away." -Moroccan Proverb

Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Rafael Gonzalez on March 24, 2012, 03:38:52 AM
It is not unhindered. You have to have light to see the pencil writings deep underwater... LL~ LL~ LL~ It is not redundant if the light source breaks either....  H^^
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: RC Storick on March 24, 2012, 03:46:39 AM
Sign Language
Title: Re: Here is one to ponder
Post by: Chris Wilson on March 25, 2012, 04:38:55 PM
Sign Language

How would human signing work in the 'extreme pressures underwater in the deepest ocean?'