News:

 

CLICK HERE--><--CLICK HERE

Effect of wind on maneuvers

Started by Matt Piatkowski, November 01, 2019, 06:28:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Matt Piatkowski

Hi PJ Rowland and Air Ministry,
Please see https://stunthanger.com/smf/open-forum/counter-rotating-propellers-for-stunt for the information about the issues you mentioned here yesterday.
I would suggest to stay on topic of this thread and the topic is " Effect of wind on maneuvers".
Thank you,
M

Matt Piatkowski

Hello,
Please see the attached vectors analysis. The inside loop was selected for this analysis. 5 m/sec. wind will cause the model velocity increase of 1.91 m/sec. while the model is flying down at 9 o'clock.
Please note that the air resistance (drag) of any flying object grows with the square of velocity. This is why the models with the counter-rotating propellers speed-up less in maneuvers. The effective drag area for contras is larger and, because the air resistance (R) is proportional to the velocity squared, the effect of air resistance for contras grows faster than the increase in the contras velocity caused by the wind.

Happy (indoor) flying,
M




Brett Buck

#27
Quote from: Matt Piatkowski on November 14, 2019, 06:42:51 AM
Please note that the air resistance (drag) of any flying object grows with the square of velocity. This is why the models with the counter-rotating propellers speed-up less in maneuvers. The effective drag area for contras is larger and, because the air resistance (R) is proportional to the velocity squared, the effect of air resistance for contras grows faster than the increase in the contras velocity caused by the wind.

     This has nothing to do with contra-rotation - the  rate of change of "drag" forward velocity could be the same with two props running the same direction, or with one larger prop. The rate of change of "drag"  with the same size prop would be higher if it was lower pitch and spinning faster, or if the engine fed back more with load, or if the Igor gadget had the gain turned up higher. It's not "drag", anyway, it's reduced thrust, not "negative thrust" - it's not really slowing you down, it's speeding you up less than it would have.

   The "area" difference you postulate doesn't necessarily exist, it might in some cases, and not in others, depending on the characteristics of the forward prop and the rear prop. You could easily choose a rear prop that squeezes your "free stream" diameter smaller as much as it would be larger. Setting it up as you describe suggests that you are blowing a lot of power having the rear prop impede the flow from the front prop - which is inconsistent with your previous observation that it was more efficient and used less battery. You are computing this mythical "area" and treating it like a pure drag source, which it certainly is not.

What you are searching for, as previously noted, is the partial derivative of the propulsion thrust with respect to forward velocity. The higher that is, the more it controls the airspeed. There's a lot more going into it than just the "area" of the prop.  It may well be higher with two props having twice the area of the same single prop, which is likely the cause of your observation, but could easily be replicated with a single prop that is larger, has more blade area, or with two of them turning the same way. You are treating it like it was just a drag source, which it is definitely not, it actually changes *much more* than with the square of the velocity on properly-operating IC engines, and if you have an accelerometer feedback system, it can be function of more than the current apparent airspeed -since the accelerometer acts with respect to the change in inertial velocity, not airspeed.

     Brett

p.s. as an aside, adding induced drag, as suggested earlier, would make the problem much worse, because a very large part of the whip-up issue is a function of the variation of the induced drag from the top to the bottom of a loop - lots of lift/induced drag at the bottom, and a whole lot less lift/induced drag at the top. With constant thrust, you would get tremendous velocity increase, just "dynamic soaring". You would be better off in this regard by adding *parasitic* drag, and adding enough extra power to overcome it - that's what everyone did with ST60 airplanes, the most famous example being the Patternmaster, and Ted and I probably overdid it on the Trivial Pursuit and Infinity. It's overdone because it, combined with the engine response partials noted above, *works too well* to maintain the airspeed in some situations.

Matt Piatkowski

Guys,
I have provided my explanation, formulas and graphs.
If you have another one, please publish it but be specific.
Best Regards,
M

Chuck_Smith

Propulsion is propulsion. Newton applies to props. At the end of the day the thrust is the time rate change of momentum of the air affected by the prop.

Contra rotating props allow smaller disks to get the same power absorption with smaller prop, exactly the same as switching from a 2 blade to 4 blade prop. A contra rotating prop is usually chosen for efficiency - provided the design trade-off of the extra weight and thus loss in payload supports the exercise. By using smaller contra rotating props the tip speed which is the vector sum of the R*omegadot (rotational speed in radians/t times blade length) PLUS the forward velocity of the airframe is reduced and compressibility affects are similarly negated as the tip speed moves lower than sonic.

How does this apply to CLPA ship? Doubtful it means much EXCEPT that the rotation in the slipstream *may* be less and thus the rolling moment due to the slipstream's impingement on the tail surfaces may be less.

It should also be fairly torque neutral regarding the moment that gets passed from the motor to the mount. Thinking about that in basic Newtonian physics - that would have to mean the net change in angular momentum of the slipstream should be new zero as well. I have held an electric Contra rotating system in my hand there was no noticeable torque I had to overcome. That makes me think the slipstream will be pretty straight IF the rear prop pitch is correct.  Choosing the correct pitch for the rear prop is a real science in itself and I'm certainly not the guy to speak to that.

Chuck
AMA 76478

Matt Piatkowski

Hello Chuck,
There is no doubts that the Newtonian Mechanics applies to the C/L flying. You are also right about the straightening of the air flow behind the counter-rotating propellers. This is the main reason that people using this propulsion system can use the LiPo batteries of lower capacity and still fly the entire pattern. They are simply getting about 15% more thrust for the same battery use. I fly my single prop. Big Red using the 6S 2800 mAh. ThunderPower battery and, after the pattern, there is about 800 mAh. left. The best Polish F2B pilot, Krystian Borzecki, uses 6S 2300 mAh. battery for his contra plane and there is about 600 mAh. left after his pattern. You are also right regarding the torques - they indeed cancel each other. Consequently, the gyroscopic yawing moment in corners is zero. Six pilots flying the contra system in Poland, use either two 12x6 two blade carbon composite propellers or one 12x6 and one (aft) 11.5 x 6. I believe the aft prop. should have a slightly smaller diameter but, at this moment, nobody really knows for sure what is better for the pattern. New propellers, having sometimes "weird" shapes are being constantly tested by the top F2B contra fliers in my old country and, in general, there is a lot of development work before the WCh in C/L in Wloclawek 2020.
Best Regards,
M



M Spencer

#31
NOW ! .

Everyone knows if you hold a spinning bicycle wheel by the axle , and lift it it goes sideways , & V c V .

So we need to hold TWO bicycle wheels and see if the do the same thing spinning opposite directions .  VD~

Or we could get two bicycle wheels on ONE AXLE  , get Brett to hold it . And spin them  in opposite rotations .
To see what happens . When he lifts or moves it L & R or drops it .  ;D

Gyro & P would by canceled or substantially negated .

I think the only way to observe the airflow is with visable air , & whilst airborne by camera on airframe. Aimed at props .
Id thats whats being investigated .
Clunk tanks , and flap movement through manouvres would be of intest also .

==========================================================================

" How does this apply to CLPA ship? Doubtful it means much  "

On nasty little British Aircraft Carriers , it meant a great deal . Like with a Jet .

When the more powerfull Griffon Spitfire was introduced , The throttle had to be progressively opened . . .
as the swing W F O on the ground was uncontrolable .
However . You dont get ' swing ' with the Contra Props .

NOW , WIND .

Is comparable to Acceleration & deceleration .
Where the Torque Reaction is prominant .

WIND - Varying Airspeed . Even if its just steady wind . It'd be Headwind & tailwind .
Thus the BALANCE of the forces on the airframe at the start & exit of manouvres ,
As well as those through them ,
Would be significant .

Most will have noticed a reluctance for the nose to raise from level , down wind . If it blowing past 18 Kts .
Also the entry to Clover & the turn into the top leg of the hourglass can be problematic . In severe wind .

Be intresred in Matt P's observations there .

Been looking for a ' everything down ' Picture of a Seafire 47 on approach . Contra Props .
A Go Around with a conventional prop , from ' on the verg ' is problematic in the extremme .
Whereas with the contra props it is almost routine .

IN WIND , particularly choppy air , for AEROBATICS , the contra props likely are a significant advantage .

================================================================

A aside , was that the forward area increase ( from dual propellors ) needed compensateing tail area for directional stabilty ,
the rear area being a bit marginal on the Supermarines , bar the very last series .

Howard Rush

I think Sina Goudarzi should have one of these systems.  He'll be his country's stunt team at the WC. 
The Jive Combat Team
Making combat and stunt great again

Chuck_Smith

Matt,

Cool data there. What we need is test on an airframe with and without.

Me, put in a big block with a pipe. If it speeds up in the air lengthen the pipe. If it slows down, shorten it.  Duh.

From that point on, kick tire and light the fire. Needle will never move.

Much simpler.

I have built electric and what I've found is that the batteries are so inconsistent it's a crapshoot. "C" ratings aren't worth the ink they used to print them. On an R/C ship it gets hidden by the left stick. On a Stunt ship it becomes glaringly obvious.

Chuck
AMA 76478

Matt Piatkowski

Hi Howard,
What country Sina Goudarzi represents?

Hi Chuck,
I hope to test the contra powered model next season. Then we will know a little more.

Regarding "C" rating: please read https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?1608752-A-simple-way-to-estimate-the-true-C-rating-of-a-LiPo-battery.
Thanks, M

Howard Rush

Quote from: Matt Piatkowski on November 16, 2019, 09:00:05 AM
What country Sina Goudarzi represents?

I regret that I have made a joke that you would not be expected to understand: it's an American history joke.  I am somewhat disappointed that no Americans responded, but it's also not very funny.  Other jokes in this thread relate to aerodynamics or dynamics. 

On the subject of American history, do you recognize the insignia on the side of my posts (not the rotating gear)?

The Jive Combat Team
Making combat and stunt great again

Howard Rush

Quote from: Howard Rush on November 11, 2019, 04:02:59 PM
On the US West coast, we are using multiple propellers, but not stacking them in tandem.  Below is David Shorts's wonderful trimotor.  Under construction are stunters with four and even six propellers. 

No joke here:
The Jive Combat Team
Making combat and stunt great again

Matt Piatkowski

Hi Howard,
Many history jokes are "country specific" and indeed hard to understand for the "outsiders".
I visited https://www.warhistoryonline.com/history/rule-one-book-war-not-march-moscow-unless-polish.html and educated myself about Merian C. Cooper and Polish 7th Air Escadrille. Extraordinary piece of history!

Does this six motors Score fly the entire pattern? What is it's RTF weight?

Best Regards,
M


Howard Rush

The Jive Combat Team
Making combat and stunt great again

Matt Piatkowski

Hi Howard,
Score's wings area with flaps is: 677sq in. ==> 677/144 = 4.70 sq. ft.
2438 grams = 86 oz.

Wing's loading is: 86/4.7 = 18.3 oz. / sq. ft.

Most currently flying competition C/L stunt planes, fully fueled or with batteries, has the wings loading in 13.2-14.2 oz. / sq. ft. range. Their level velocity is around 25 m/sec. and the lap times are within 5.0-5.3 sec.

The electric, six motor Score will have to fly really fast to maintain the lines tension in the pattern and certainly it is not a competition plane.

You probably know that Paul Walker built B-17 with four glow engines in 2000. Please see . It is a unique example of the very good pattern flown by the almost scale control line, multi-engine model.

Best Regards,
M


Howard Rush

Quote from: Matt Piatkowski on November 19, 2019, 09:41:23 AM
You probably know that Paul Walker built B-17 with four glow engines in 2000.

I think I heard about it from the fat guy flipping switches on the battery box in that video.
The Jive Combat Team
Making combat and stunt great again

Brett Buck

#41
This is the (greatly simplified) basis for speed stability based on the prop and (for sake of simplicity) a constant RPM. It shows the drag as a function of velocity, which goes up as the airspeed increases, and the thrust from this simplified situation for two example cases, one with identical props, but one with 6" of pitch and the necessary RPM to get the required airspeed, and 4" of pitch and the much higher RPM required to get the same inflight speed.



     I will give you the basis of this (and a way to model it {using numerical integration of the lift at each point along the radius} that seems to have worked well over the years), but it takes a fair bit of background work to fully explain. It's not that complicated, but it takes a lot of preamble. It's also largely as previously discussed at extraordinary length on SSW.

  What you see is the expected static thrust difference (that anyone who has launched a ST46 and 40VF airplane back-to-back), much higher for the 4" pitch prop. A fair bit of the 6" pitch prop is stalled on the ground near the root, so as the velocity increases, it progressively unstalls and the thrust rises for a while, then starts falling as the angle of attack of the prop blades goes down does as the airspeed goes up. Less of the 4" pitch prop is stalled on the ground, so it both has much more thrust (due to the much higher dynamic pressure, ~67% more) and less "knee" in the curve at low velocities.

   The result is that the thrust falls much faster with respect to the airspeed for a 4" pitch prop than it does for a 6" pitch prop, for the same inflight thrust/speed. Since the acceleration at any particular is the difference between the thrust and the drag (divided by the mass), a steeper slope (partial derivative of the thrust with respect to forward velocity) means more acceleration for "perturbed" velocity , or a smaller change in velocity for a given perturbation. That, ST60 fans, is why it doesn't work as well as a 40VF, and why a Fox doesn't work nearly as well as a 20FP.

    Note that this is for identical props, the only difference being the pitch. To first approximation, doubling the blade area doubles the static thrust, meaning when set to get the same thrust at the same airspeed, the slope is much steeper. This is like using a 4-blade prop instead of a 2-blade - or having to nominally identical props spinning in opposite directions.

   There are of course, significant simplification to make this amenable to analysis, for example, it assumes a constant RPM, which essentially never happens, even with an RPM governor electric, although it's closer than any other system. It considers nothing at all about the engine torque response, and there is *much* more happening with either a IC engine or  accelerometer feedback system. But it does illustrate the basic and strongest effect in principle.


    Systems with better airspeed control have a larger slope of this curve at the operating point.

    Brett
     

Brett Buck

#42
The reason the curves shown above exist is because the angle of attack of the prop changes with forward speed. To understand why, and to begin to be able to approximate the effect analytically, we need to understand the angle of attack at various points along the prop radius. Of course, it is different depending on the pitch of the prop.

   The pitch is defined as how far the prop would travel forward in one revolution, if it didn't "slip". Of course it always does, but the angle of "something", usually the back of the blade, has to be something, and it's not the same angle from root to tip - its much steeper at the root than the tip. The due to the fact that in one revolution, different parts of the blade travel different total distances.



   The drawing shows the points at a radius (distance from the prop shaft) of 2", 4", or 6") with a hypothetical 6" of pitch. In one revolution, they all go the same distance up and down (direction of flight) , but closer to the shaft, it moves less around the circumference of circle. Imagine "unwinding" each spiral and flattening it out to get wedges:



The angle of the wedge gets lower as you go out the prop. The angle is the blade angle associated with the back of the blade. That's why it gets flatter near the tips.

At a given radius r, the "length" of the wedge is 2pi*r, and the height is the pitch. So, in this example:

r=2"        length = ~12.6"
r=4"        length = ~25.2"
r=6"        length = ~37.7"

The tangent of the blade angle (alpha)  = rise/run = 6"/length, so, alpha = arctan(pitch/length)

r=2"   alpha = 24.5 degrees
r=4"  alpha = 13.4 degrees
r=6"  alpha = 9.04 degrees

    This is the angle measured by a prop pitch gauge - it's really just a protractor calibrated in inches. Of course, a 4" prop pitch has lower angles at the same point:

r=2" alpha = 17.6 degrees
r=4" alpha = 9.02 degrees
r=6" alpha = 6.05 degrees

Of course, it works at any radius, and can be computed at as many points as you want (which will come in handy later):



    Brett






M Spencer



You forgot to put some on the tailplane ! .  ;D

Howard Rush

I just received a report that the above six-motor airplane has done all the maneuvers. I also learned that the motor rotation direction differs between wings.
The Jive Combat Team
Making combat and stunt great again

Tim Wescott

Quote from: Brett Buck on November 20, 2019, 11:11:08 PM
The result is that the thrust falls much faster with respect to the airspeed for a 4" pitch prop than it does for a 6" pitch prop, for the same inflight thrust/speed.

OOH!  So we should use zero-pitch props.  Because they go so fast, we can drive them by zero-displacement engines!
AMA 64232

The problem with electric is that once you get the smoke generator and sound system installed, the plane is too heavy.

Brett Buck

Quote from: Tim Wescott on November 22, 2019, 02:06:34 PM
OOH!  So we should use zero-pitch props.  Because they go so fast, we can drive them by zero-displacement engines!

  Of infinite RPM and HP.

   In point of fact, we started out with 46VFs running 3.25" of pitch and 12,000 rpm, they would seem as if they were barely moving, and were almost immune to high steady winds - if you were willing to wait for it . That's the basis of my first post above  - you can build systems of such speed stability that it is excessive, counter-rotating or otherwise.

   Brett

Chuck_Smith

Good stuff Brett.  Yep that's true of all air breathing propulsion systems, even turbojets. The faster you go, the more the thrust drops off. Even if you can control the pitch you end up at some point with the flow through the combustion chamber thermally choked and you hit the momentum exchange limit.  That's when you light the rockets, since their thrust isn't velocity dependent.

The engineering paper is a nice touch too!

Chuck

AMA 76478

Brett Buck

Quote from: Chuck_Smith on November 22, 2019, 04:59:30 PM
The engineering paper is a nice touch too!

   It's the paper I have...

   If I really wanted to show off, I would dig out a "<<large aerospace contractor>> Stress Sheet", which was something similar to the generic engineering pad that we had custom-printed for us, on yellow paper, and was probably the place almost every new idea in the space age started (long before I was here - for instance, someone has the yellow stress sheet where they scribbled down the first block diagram for orbital gyrocompassing in 1956, framed, up on their wall).

   I actually prefer the green generic version, but I save the yellow ones (which haven't been produced for about 15 years now) to lend credence to whatever stupid idea I come up with.

    Brett

Chuck_Smith

But as I think about this thread I must have had some old synapse fire off - maybe there is a fundamental advantage to electric power for stunt speed control.

On electric, the back emf reduces the torque as the rpm increases. That's a big deal and we can use it to our advantage.

Chuck
AMA 76478


Advertise Here