Peter the 2 motors are mostly the same size in fuse width , and the ST is slightly lighter, Both of those engine will run a good 4/2, but at higher RPMs. I do not know which engine models you have, as both were made in CL versions, If assuming they both are, I would opt for the st 51. I ran a Sig Magnum with a COMO 51 for a couple of years, It was about a perfect engine for it, and as you may know the COMO was a ST built engine. I used a 12 x 5 with the 51, and I would use a 12 x 4 wide, or a 12.5 x 4.5 with the OS FSR 45. YOu can also use the 12 x 4.5 3 blade with that engine. The BOLLY 12 1/4 x 4 1/4 would be a very good prop for the FSR too
First thing you have to do is see which version engines you have
Randy