News:

 

CLICK HERE--><--CLICK HERE

Thrust and bearings

Started by BillLee, August 18, 2026, 06:49:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

BillLee

In a other thread, Lauri Mallila said
Quotein our engines, it's the front bearing that takes the axial loads (for the beforementioned reasons).

I have heard that before as well as that it is the rear bearing. I would like to hear comments either way, but would really like to see some references.

Anybody?

Regards,

Bill Lee
Bill Lee
AMA 20018

spare_parts

In all engines I've measured, the front bearing takes the thrust load. By design, only the inner race of the front bearing is clamped, and there is a clearance between the rear inner race and the crank web shoulder. I don't get into engines with shimmed front bearings but I understand this is done to set axial clearance of the crank and case assembly. In this case, thrust is taken by the rear bearing.
Greg

Lauri Malila

Hi Bill,

That's how I do it, in my own stuff and in the quite many Retro's etc. I have prepared and fixed.
Remember that here we talk about stunt engines, with lower power output and in general much less stress than in racing engines. Read Robbie's FMV-story, the racing engine bearing problematic is very well explained there.
Anyway, what works for us is a tight sliding fit between shaft and rear bearing, so tight that it won't slide during running, but so loose that the inner ring finds its place on shaft during the first seconds or minutes of running.
In that kind of setup, apart from the fit itself, the front bearing fit to case has to be strong enough to carry the axial forces, and you must leave a small gap between the rear face of rear bearing inner ring and the shaft shoulder in front of crank web. Something like o,2...0,25mm is usually enough. That allows the ring to float to its place and it also allows the slight movement because of differences in thermal expansion of shaft and case. L
 

Brett Buck

Quote from: BillLee on August 18, 2026, 06:49:17 AMIn a other thread, Lauri Mallila said
I have heard that before as well as that it is the rear bearing. I would like to hear comments either way, but would really like to see some references.


  One end or the other has to free-float axially, otherwise, you are putting in an axial preload, which is both draggy and effectively impossible to control over temperature.

    On almost all ball bearing engines, the thrust washer or collet bears directly one side of the inner race of the front bearing, and the crank bears on the other side, it is hard clamped together by tightening the prop. The front bearing can't slide freely in the pocket, so the thrust washer, crank, bearing is fixed in position. Since you have to have clearance, that means the rear *has* to have some axial float.

   Of course, you could do it the other way, but you would then have to have some way for the shaft to float axially on the front, meaning you need a step or wedge in the crankshaft for the thrust washer to bear. Plain-bearing engines work this way, the thrust load is at the crank web to the case.

   It make far more sense to me, given the very minimal thrust loads, and extremely large radial loads at the rear,  to take the thrust with the typically tiny front bearing and take the firing load with a large rear bearing. That puts the heavy load entirely in the radial direction where it is designed to work. and the axial loading is so minimal that the front works even though you are putting the load in the wrong direction.

  Note also the other thread where we are discussing, tangentially, angular contact bearings intended to provide very accurate location of the shaft, at the cost of having to preload it axially. That is common/universal in precision devices (gyros and spacecraft reaction wheels or control moment gyros) where the shaft wobble or other dynamic motion is critical, but even in very controlled situations, determining the correct preload and maintaining it is extremely difficult. It would be very nuts to try to put that in a model engine selling for $100 and/or maybe eating dirt from time to time, in a terrible lubrication environment.

   Brett

   

Steve Glass

Informative Informative x 1 View List



Advertise Here