News:

 

CLICK HERE--><--CLICK HERE

Sport Engine Bearing Replacement

Started by Colin McRae, August 17, 2026, 11:18:36 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Colin McRae

I'm replacing the bearings on an Evolution 36NT sport engine and have a couple questions on the new bearings. This is the 1st time I have ever replaced bearings so please bear with me.

I heated up the case in an oven, and both of the old bearings easily came out.

The original stock bearings on the EVO 36 engine both were open type (no seals). Probably why the bearings didn't last very long.

The new bearing kit I have from Boca uses an open design back bearing (with offset ball race) and a front bearing with rubber seals on both sides. On the front bearing, the Bocca specs say that it is factory grease lubricated.

1. On the front Boca bearing, is it recommended to retain both rubber seals, or remove the rear facing rubber seal, but retain the front facing seal for external debris protection? 

2. On the Boca rear open-type bearing (with offset ball race), the balls are easily seen from one end, but are somewhat hidden by the nylon retainer on the other side. The offset ball race is more towards the fully open side of the bearing. It is my understanding that the fully open side should face rearward (towards the rear cover on the case) for proper lubrication. Is this the correct orientation for the new Boca rear bearing?

Thanks in advance

Colin






Brett Buck

Quote from: Colin McRae on August 17, 2026, 11:18:36 AMI'm replacing the bearings on an Evolution 36NT sport engine and have a couple questions on the new bearings. This is the 1st time I have ever replaced bearings so please bear with me.

I heated up the case in an oven, and both of the old bearings easily came out.

The original stock bearings on the EVO 36 engine both were open type (no seals). Probably why the bearings didn't last very long.

The new bearing kit I have from Boca uses an open design back bearing (with offset balls) and a front bearing with rubber seals on both sides. On the front bearing, the Bocca specs say that it is factory grease lubricated.

1. On the front Boca bearing, is it recommended to retain both rubber seals, or remove the rear facing rubber seal, but retain the front facing seal for external debris protection? 

2. On the Boca rear open-type bearing (with offset balls), the balls are easily seen from one end, but are somewhat hidden by the nylon retainer on the other side. The offset balls are more towards the fully open side of the bearing. It is my understanding that the fully open side should face rearward (towards the rear cover on the case) for proper lubrication. Is this the correct orientation for the new Boca rear bearing?
Colin


   It doesn't matter very much, but I would remove one of the seals on the front bearing, and put the seal to the front, open at the back. I would probably put the rear in with the retainer in front.

   Bearing in mind that each bearing *must* be seated all the way to the bottom of its pocket, and only push on it by the outer race, DO NOT push it by the inner race. Make sure that the pockets are perfectly clean to make sure nothing prevents it from going all the way to the bottom.
   
    Brett

Colin McRae

Quote from: Brett Buck on August 17, 2026, 11:54:51 AMIt doesn't matter very much, but I would remove one of the seals on the front bearing, and put the seal to the front, open at the back. I would probably put the rear in with the retainer in front.
 
    Brett

Thx Brett, that makes sense.

I have been doing some reading on this subject and it seems like 50/50 where people remove one of the front seals (one facing inward). I guess the grease will eventually go away and the bearing lubed by the fuel.

On the back open bearing, having the open side to the rear (retainer side to the front) enhances fuel lubrication and also increases the bearing span a little) due to the offset balls. The slightly longer bearing span probably offers better crankshaft support. Why else would Boca offset the balls.

Colin


Brett Buck

Quote from: Colin McRae on August 17, 2026, 12:15:54 PMThx Brett, that makes sense.

I have been doing some reading on this subject and it seems like 50/50 where people remove one of the front seals (one facing inward). I guess the grease will eventually go away and the bearing lubed by the fuel.

On the back open bearing, having the open side to the rear (retainer side to the front) enhances fuel lubrication and also increases the bearing span a little) due to the offset balls. The slightly longer bearing span probably offers better crankshaft support. Why else would Boca offset the balls.

Colin



  I am not sure what you are talking about with an "offset". The phenolic or whatever retainers are asymmetrical but as far as I know the balls run right in the middle of the outer ring.

    Brett
Old Old x 1 View List

Colin McRae

Quote from: Brett Buck on August 17, 2026, 02:07:34 PMI am not sure what you are talking about with an "offset". The phenolic or whatever retainers are asymmetrical but as far as I know the balls run right in the middle of the outer ring.

    Brett

Not on this particular Boca rear open bearing. The balls are not centered between the faces, but are 'offset' closer to one face.

This was a more 'high-performance' bearing kit for the EVO 36 that Boca had to offer. They had several different kits, but the bearing kit I got was the only kit offered for the EVO 36 with an open type rear bearing. Advertised as offering increased load capacity and higher rpm. Probably more designed for racing engines, but again the only kit offered with an open rear bearing design. I'm sure it's fine but just overkill for a sport engine.

I've already completed the installation. Super smooth now.

Colin

Mark wood



2. On the Boca rear open-type bearing (with offset balls), the balls are easily seen from one end, but are somewhat hidden by the nylon retainer on the other side. The offset balls are more towards the fully open side of the bearing. It is my understanding that the fully open side should face rearward (towards the rear cover on the case) for proper lubrication. Is this the correct orientation for the new Boca rear bearing?

Thanks in advance

Colin
[/quote]

Yeah that is a thrust bearing. Typical in turbine engines where thrust levels in the rotors are high. The thrust level on our engines aren't that high but it doesn't hurt to install these types of bearings. They are designed with that "ramp" to carry those thrust loads. The "taper" offsets the contact path a bit in order to carry the axial loading, thrust. A straight bearing isn't designed to carry much axial load. The thrust bearings have a lower rolling friction under axial loading than the standard bearing. Hence being the upgrade. The installation instructions are correct. The side where you can see more of the balls is the aft side.
Life is good AMA 1488
Why do we fly? We are practicing, you might say, what it means to be alive...  -Richard Bach
"Physics is like sex: sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it." – Richard P. Feynman
Take off's are optional. Landings are mandatory, it's only a question of quality.

Lauri Malila




Yeah that is a thrust bearing. Typical in turbine engines where thrust levels in the rotors are high. The thrust level on our engines aren't that high but it doesn't hurt to install these types of bearings. They are designed with that "ramp" to carry those thrust loads. The "taper" offsets the contact path a bit in order to carry the axial loading, thrust. A straight bearing isn't designed to carry much axial load. The thrust bearings have a lower rolling friction under axial loading than the standard bearing. Hence being the upgrade. The installation instructions are correct. The side where you can see more of the balls is the aft side.
[/quote]

If you mean "thrust bearing" as an angular contact bearing, then that is absolutely not the case.
With angular contact and the radial impulses from ignition, the result would be catastrophic.
Besides, in our engines, it's the front bearing that takes the axial loads (for the beforementioned reasons).
The offset ball groove is something that you can see in modern racing engines, it's kind of a second best option after an integral bearing where ball groove is machined directly to crankshaft.
The idea is just to move the groove closer to crankweb/crankpin, for less deformation.
In this case, the Evolution, i'd think that the benefit is quite homeophatical. But a nice detail anyway. L
Old Old x 1 View List

Brett Buck

Quote from: Lauri Malila on August 18, 2026, 06:13:58 AMIf you mean "thrust bearing" as an angular contact bearing, then that is absolutely not the case.
With angular contact and the radial impulses from ignition, the result would be catastrophic.
Besides, in our engines, it's the front bearing that takes the axial loads (for the beforementioned reasons).

    I agree that Mark appears to be describing an angular contact bearing, not a thrust bearing. I think in principle it would be fine, but based on extensive painful experience, I am pretty sure that you would never, ever get the preload to be consistent enough in a model engine. And there is no need to do it - you don't need high precision shaft positioning in either direction, and the level of preload required would be very draggy.

   These little front bearings are only taking a axial load of maybe 5 lbs in an extreme case, and hardly any torque from precession or p-factor, so they are OK. The rear is the one that takes the pounding and I can't recall a case where I had a front chip or fail from load. I have had several rears fail from load, presumably radial load ( which looks to be well north of 200 lbs on even stunt engines).

    Brett

Colin McRae

Quote from: Brett Buck on August 18, 2026, 10:12:15 AMI can't recall a case where I had a front chip or fail from load. I have had several rears fail from load, presumably radial load ( which looks to be well north of 200 lbs on even stunt engines).

    Brett

On my EVO 36 with original bearings it was the rear bearing that failed. The retainer was broken at one location. Front bearing looked to be OK. And there was really not much time on the engine.

I realize the EVO engines were made in China and the bearings looked to be of poor quality. In comparison, the new Boca bearings look to be much better quality-wise.

Also, I got the engine NIB from an estate and the paperwork mentions year 2008. So, the engine was in the box before use for around 16 years. Sitting around all that time probably had something to do with premature bearing failure. The bearings had no sign of corrosion or anything like that. Just poor-quality bearings I believe.

Colin

Mark wood

I stand corrected. It isn't a thrust bearing per se. In the turbines they are usually pared in opposite directions which preloads them and keeps the rotor in place. I didn't realzie the point that not being properly in the model engine they would more than likely skid.
Life is good AMA 1488
Why do we fly? We are practicing, you might say, what it means to be alive...  -Richard Bach
"Physics is like sex: sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it." – Richard P. Feynman
Take off's are optional. Landings are mandatory, it's only a question of quality.

Motorman

#10
Colin, You may have a smooth turning assembly but, if you followed the above advise, you've set your crank pin too far to the rear. On a sport engine it probably doesn't matter with the small amounts we are dealing with but you never want to seat the front bearing in it's pocket. It's meant to have clearance back there. Some custon made or high end engines are designed for the front bearing to be seated in the pocket and have the crank hang out a little in the back but production engines are not like that.

You need a tool to install the front bearing. A piece of round stock slightly smaller than the OD and a center hole that's slightly bigger than the prop shaft. This will hold the races of the front bearing in alignement while you press it down on to the crankshaft which should be proud of the bearing pocket. The key is to heat the case above the operating temp of the engine while pressing so the bearings never get a preload under normal conditions.

MM






Wasted words ain't never been heard. Alman Brothers

Brett Buck

Quote from: Colin McRae on August 18, 2026, 11:41:54 AMI realize the EVO engines were made in China and the bearings looked to be of poor quality. In comparison, the new Boca bearings look to be much better quality-wise.

Also, I got the engine NIB from an estate and the paperwork mentions year 2008. So, the engine was in the box before use for around 16 years. Sitting around all that time probably had something to do with premature bearing failure. The bearings had no sign of corrosion or anything like that. Just poor-quality bearings I believe.

    Sitting around, lots of times the lubricants turn to sludge/wax/concrete, and make them feel notchy as you try to turn it. It will usually be OK if you can get the sludge cleaned out, but that's not very easy.

     Brett

Colin McRae

#12
Quote from: Motorman on August 18, 2026, 12:58:01 PMColin, You may have a smooth turning assembly but, if you followed the above advise, you've set your crank pin too far to the rear. On a sport engine it probably doesn't matter with the small amounts we are dealing with but you never want to seat the front bearing in it's pocket. It's meant to have clearance back there. Some custon made or high end engines are designed for the front bearing to be seated in the pocket and have the crank hang out a little in the back but production engines are not like that.

You need a tool to install the front bearing. A piece of round stock slightly smaller than the OD and a center hole that's slightly bigger than the prop shaft. This will hold the races of the front bearing in alignement while you press it down on to the crankshaft which should be proud of the bearing pocket. The key is to heat the case above the operating temp of the engine while pressing so the bearings never get a preload under normal conditions.

MM








The new Boca bearings have the exact same dimensions as the EVO stock ones. So, they are fully seated in the case. The crankshaft position is unchanged from stock. The only difference is that the ball race location 'within' the back bearing is a bit further aft from stock.

Did not need a 'special' tool to remove or install the EVO 36 bearings. Boca had a nice DYI video on how to replace bearings on a typical sport engine. With oven heating of the case the old bearings simply popped out. Then reheated the case to insert the new bearings. Was very easy to install per the video and the new bearings are fully seated properly within the case.

Colin




Brett Buck

Quote from: Mark wood on August 18, 2026, 12:33:52 PMI stand corrected. It isn't a thrust bearing per se. In the turbines they are usually pared in opposite directions which preloads them and keeps the rotor in place. I didn't realzie the point that not being properly in the model engine they would more than likely skid.

  Angular-contact bearings are a very tricky system. You only really want them where the shaft motion has to be precisely controlled for performance of vibration control purposes, and to avoid some of the damaging effect of the shaft wobbling around (because as it wobbles, the film thickness can get locally thin, thinner that the roughness, so you get either mixed or boundary lubrication.

  Even the crudest ball bearings, used incorrectly for the local loads (like the thrust appearing as an axial load on a relatively tiny bearing), are far more than good enough to shaft location purposes in a model engine and lets you use extremely crude lubrication methods - like, flooding it with oil hoping that some makes it to the front bearing with no intentional mechanism to get it there.

  Tribology and bearing design is one step from astrology. I am most certainly NOT an expert, my exposure/troubleshooting of various gyro rotor/reaction wheel/control moment gyro performance and reliability gave me some of the basics. Spacecraft gyro rotors require extreme precision in the shaft location, and many of the various retainer and precession/nutation modes can quickly destroy the bearings. Even with the same nominal design and specifications, one gyro might perform poorly and wear out in a month, others from the same batch might run for 30+ years with remarkable stability. When I left, I had one gyro that had run essentially perfectly (at 14,400 rpm) for 30+ years and no signs of degradation.

    Brett

p.s. When talking to Lockheed tribology experts about reaction wheel bearings, and whether low-speed operation was risky, the same expert proclaimed that we should never run it below 100ish  rpm due to disproportionate wear/rev in boundary lubrication, and later in the same argument, claim that it didn't matter what you did if we kept it below 2,000,000 total revs - meaning running it slowly. What we actually did was run it however it needed, ignored the Stribeck curve (which we could easily extract from flight data and plot out, looks like the textbooks) and let it run around zero for as long as it needed. Again, last I looked, 30+ years in flight and no hint of wear, and something like 5 years on the ground in pre-launch test.

Brett Buck

Quote from: Colin McRae on August 18, 2026, 02:00:49 PMDid not need a special tool to remove or install the EVO 36 bearings. Boca had a nice DYI video on how to replace bearings on a typical sport engine. With oven heating of the case the old bearings simply popped out. Then reheated the case to insert the new bearings. Was very easy to install per the video and the new bearings are fully seated properly within the case.

   The difference is that the crankshaft might be cantilevered by an additional 1/16" or so depending on which way the offset lies. I think for low-performance system like this, your big hardened steel crankshaft can stand the extra bending. I would just leave it whatever way it wound up and not worry about it.

   Stuff like this *does* matter in other cases, I recall when some British guys built the first model-size turbojet, they had to worry about the shaft "whipping" like a jump rope between two bearings - that were maybe an inch or so apart, and was (again) steel about 3/8" OD! This was at *100,000 rpm" or so, as I recall.

    Brett

Colin McRae

Quote from: Brett Buck on August 18, 2026, 02:12:22 PMThe difference is that the crankshaft might be cantilevered by an additional 1/16" or so depending on which way the offset lies. I think for low-performance system like this, your big hardened steel crankshaft can stand the extra bending. I would just leave it whatever way it wound up and not worry about it.

 

    Brett

In my case the opposite. The 'offset' balls within the bearing are actually closer to the crankpin so the cantilever length is shorter. But the bearing span now is a bit longer from stock by the same amount, maybe 1.5-2mm. The overall bearing width is 6mm.

I'm not worried :)

Colin

Lauri Malila

Quote from: Motorman on August 18, 2026, 12:58:01 PMColin, You may have a smooth turning assembly but, if you followed the above advise, you've set your crank pin too far to the rear. On a sport engine it probably doesn't matter with the small amounts we are dealing with but you never want to seat the front bearing in it's pocket. It's meant to have clearance back there. Some custon made or high end engines are designed for the front bearing to be seated in the pocket and have the crank hang out a little in the back but production engines are not like that.

MM

I'm sorry but that's not the correct way to do it. You must seat the bearing fully to bottom, first to have a hard reference point for measuring and secondly to ensure that the bearing is seated straight.
If the shaft position is not correct, you can shim either the back of outer ring or make a washer with correct thickness behind the inner ring.
L
Creative Creative x 1 View List



Advertise Here