Might want to check on a pitch gauge, often the tip pitch is more flat the the hub pitch, and the indicated pitch is somewhere in between.
Second check the blade dimensions against a prop made to the desired dimensions. The cut down blade might be too stout and heavy.
Mechanically and safety cutting props down has been done, and will continue to be done. Trim carefully and cleanly, seal, and re-balance.
Removing 3+ inches is a lot of material to remove though. It may still make sense for your setup.
Phil