News:

 

CLICK HERE--><--CLICK HERE

What Classic designs are your favorites?

Started by Bob Hunt, February 08, 2026, 09:11:48 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Bob Hunt

I grew up (or at least got older...) during the period in which the classic designs of the 1960s were in their heyday. It was an era in which there were little to no restraints on what one could design and fly in the CL Stunt event - either in rules or in one's own head... Consequently there were a huge number of very "original" designs/shapes produced, mostly around the ubiquitous Nobler wing (imagine how much Top Flite could have made if they produced just the Nobler wing in kit form...). And, many of them were extremely forgettable. But some were iconic and their influence lives on even today.

It was the many and varied shapes of the models of that era that inspired me to a great degree. There seemed to be no end to the creativity of designers of that time frame. Of course, there was not anywhere near as much research being done in the aerodynamics of most of those designs as we see today. And because there were no "rules," some amazing aesthetics were born (hatched...?). Throughout the late 1950s and early 1960s the trend seemed to be more towards 1930's race plane aesthetics. Then the "jet" phase hit with planes like Lew McFarland's Shark 45 and the Stingray and Eclipse from the mind of Bob Gialdini. And then at the very end of the 1960s there was an explosion of what Bill Simons called the "New Wave" stunters. That group included the Novi series by Dave Gierke, the Talon/Formula S designs of Jim Kostecky, and the Ultra-Sonic design by Don Bambrick - among many others. And it was that group of airplanes that started me thinking in that direction. The first results of that for me were my Tangent, Avanti, and Genesis designs, which appeared in the early 1970s.

I have my favorites from that era: The aforementioned Stingray, Eclipse, and Formula S, and the Novi IV. And my favorites from the late 1950's and early 1960's include the Tucker Special and the Charles Mackey Lark (there were actually several airplanes named "Lark" in that era). 

Okay, what are your favorites, and why?

Later - Bob Hunt     

George Grossardt

My favorite would have to be Les McDonald's Stiletto. 

Bob Hunt

#2
Great choice, George, but, unfortunately, that's not a Classic legal design. The Classic event rules stipulate that the model in question has to have been designed, built, or flown prior to midnight December 31, 1969. Les' Tropicaire (a modified version of the Formula S) just might sneak in under the Classic deadline however.

Thanks for playing, and try again... LL~ LL~

Bob

Bob Hunt

Just to prime the pump a bit, I'm going to post some photos of Classic era airplanes.

Here are two that I built some years ago. The first one is my Bob Tucker-designed Tucker Special, and the second one is my Charles Mackey-designed Lark.

Later - Bob

Ken Culbertson

#4
Bob, you opened the door for subjectivity.  My favorites, as are with many of us even if we won't admit it, our own designs.  This was my first trip to the drafting board as a Junior in High School.  It posted the high flight score at the '64 Nats in Senior and I am still flying version "V" today.  Somehow your first successful design will always be a favorite.  My girlfriend named it.  Said it reminded her of the little birds scurrying all over the place at the beach.  I should have kept that one, the girl that is. LL~

Ken
AMA 15382
If it is not broke you are not trying hard enough.
USAF 1968-1974 TAC

Bob Hunt

Hey, if that's your favorite, I'm fine with it!  y1

Bob

John Miller

Well, I still have fond memories of my green box "Nobler" I built in '58-'59. I was a real Newby back then, I knew next to nothing about trim techniques, but it flew right off the board. That was a good thing,' cause there was no easy way to make changes. I won't post a picture as I've lost the only one I had.

When I returned to Stunt, I digitized the plans, and published in the old Model Builders Magazine, with permission, Dick Williams Electra. Another design that flew off the board. It had all the adjustable features, but I only bench trimmed, moved the loadouts forward 1/8" and flew it's second flight in VSC competition. It placed well for me, about the middle of the pack. It was a great fling airplane.

About 15 years ago, Gordy and I both built Dave Gierkes (sp) All American Eagle. I finished mine in Navy Blue Angels livery. I still have it. It was another that pretty well flew off the board, though I did have to make a few trim flights to make some basic trim adjustments.

These are my favs, A tip of the hat to Palmer and Hunt's designs, but I never built one of Bubba's, and the Thunderbird 2 I built suffered from being too heavy and needing trim skills which I at 16 I didn't have so it never flew well for me.
Getting a line on life. AMA 1601

Bob Hunt

Hi John:

I have to agree with you on the Gierke designs; they were something special back then, and even today!

Here are a couple of photos of Dave's Novi III

Later - Bob


Bob Hunt

I'm also a huge fan of Gene Schaffer's designs. His airplanes were very business like, but had a certain aesthetic trademark.

Bob



M Spencer

Cant find a picture of Havel's Folkerts .

Like his philosophy . and on THESE .


A aficionado would know theres something odd here . As m y 55 500 r was the best Triumph engine ever Made !
and this 56 is the same . But 750 . Alloy . Dual Carb . likely built by one off the few ' top line ' blokes extant . Then .


John was no feul . Finer Points & subleties etc . The Talks 7 should tow one o.k. . ( If I ever get round to it )

https://www.britbike.com/forums/ubbthreads.php/topics/959390/2

Reading Mr Havels artical , youd see what he was up to since . HENCE this . Pull a easy 140 , if ' race Proep ' built .
I should think . So geared for 110 it'd see of a old 80s 1100 Katana . No Sweat . as the 500 R held one easy . ( If it were in my frame .



So , there you are . Your privledged to see what might ( if I got hold off it ) the BEST Triumph engine ever made .
As it might be better than the best one . Which is the one I had . Bout the Same Wt. plus 50 % displacement .
Redline 7800 as R std was 8000 .  pologies for zerr disgression . Not the spit n polish brigade eer .


That theres that , which I belive is this . In there , here . The same even . Motor.


1955 Senior T.T. Morrie Lowe . Honest Injun ! John Havel got into restoring ' Olde triumphs ' after . So it says .






M Spencer

AAARRRGGHHHHHH .


Same plane .


The Answer is Blowing in the Wind .  %^@

Saw a picture of this from the 60s back in 76 & a slope soaring one , which led too  :-X

Theres a comment in the artical about one splattered . Id think it was sudden total bowing of the 3 / 32 pushrod . CATASTROPHICALLY .
definately worth a read . Differant orses for differant courses . cetra . tickly since its 1960 thereabouts and evolving was where it was at .
Then .

M Spencer

For furugnas , magazines , from the U S of A were ot rods , custom cycles , and aeronautical . So the ole chrome & custom paint thing was way out . The ' detroit ' line of design , vintage . with all the ribs showing .
Like4 a Tiger moth .  S?P



THAT was the ' Brave New world ' . The Frontier . as it were . to us  pacific island utopian upstarts . The rat race was a furgin fing . Not ere Mate .

Ty Marcucci

I have to go with the Ares..I have built 7 of them..I flew my first full pattern with a slightly modified Ares in April 1969.  Up to then it was Barnstormer (1954) and Thunder Bird (1965)...
Ty Marcucci

Airacobra

There were so many designs I fell in love with as a kid that I still love today. Talon, Van Loo Chipmunk, Mystere, Bambrick Fury, Ares, Cobra...on and on of great designs  If I were to build something today, I think I would go for the ease of a straight, light, well built and finished Chief.
Keith Bryant

Bob Hunt

Quote from: Ty Marcucci on February 10, 2026, 06:55:32 PM
I have to go with the Ares..I have built 7 of them..I flew my first full pattern with a slightly modified Ares in April 1969.  Up to then it was Barnstormer (1954) and Thunder Bird (1965)...

Hi Ty:

I think just about everyone would agree that the Ares and the Nobler were the two designs that had the most influence on what was to come, at least from an aesthetic point of view. Certainly they were miles apart in respect to how they were constructed (at least the wing construction...).

I'm attaching a photo of Billy and Steve Wooley that was taken shortly after Billy had won the 1959 Nats. For those who are not aware, Billy was a Senior class flier and he beat Bob Palmer in the Walker Trophy Fly-Off that year. Steve is, of course, posing here with one of his Argus models, which was very similar to the Ares, and in fact was built by Steve in Billy's basement workshop in the same jigs and fixtures in which the Ares models were built. They were best friends. Sadly, Steve was killed in a sports car accident not too many years after this photo was taken. One of the highlights of my life was watching Steve fly his Argus at the 1961 Nats. I also watched Billy win the Senior Stunt event that year flying his Ares. Billy's presentation was both technically outstanding and also mesmerizing in flow and grace. There is a reason they call him "The Man."

Later - Bob     

Kermit Payne

I had to think about this one for a little bit.  The classic-era airplanes have what artists call "line" --- they have a flow from one part of the airframe to the next that is visually appealing to the human eye.  Of course, that appeal is very subjective and will be different from person to person, and even within one's own view it could change with time.

For pure aesthetics I have always been partial to biplanes, especially ones whose "line" can stand the test of time within my own view.  Mac-the-Bipe by Lloyd Curtis has always fit that mold for me.  It has the appearance of a Bucker Jungmeister or Stampe biplane which I have always admired.  It's on my "one of these days" list to build.  I don't believe its performance will be competitive with other classic designs but it sure will look good.

From a competitive performance perspective, I'll go with Bob Hunt's Caprice.  I have seen a few versions of this airplane fly in competitions from regional/local contests to the Nats, and it is a high performer in addition to having the aforementioned "line."  It is indeed a fine looking, fine performing airplane.

Kermit

Clint Ormosen

My top three based on looks alone would be:

JD Falcon
Williams Electra,
VanLoo Chipmunk.

The 5 Runner ups:
Klapinski Tempest
Ares
LaDonna
Lampione F86
Formula S

Now the 50 second runner ups :



Just kidding!!!


-Clint-

AMA 559593
Finding new and innovated ways to screw up the pattern since 1993

Bob Hunt

Quote from: Clint Ormosen on February 15, 2026, 06:51:36 AM
My top three based on looks alone would be:

JD Falcon
Williams Electra,
VanLoo Chipmunk.

The 5 Runner ups:
Klapinski Tempest
Ares
LaDonna
Lampione F86
Formula S

Now the 50 second runner ups :



Just kidding!!!

All good choices, Clint! I'm especially fond of the Formula S, and, in fact, all of Jim Kostecky's designs.

Bob

Bob Hunt

Quote from: Kermit Payne on February 14, 2026, 07:12:34 PM
I had to think about this one for a little bit.  The classic-era airplanes have what artists call "line" --- they have a flow from one part of the airframe to the next that is visually appealing to the human eye.  Of course, that appeal is very subjective and will be different from person to person, and even within one's own view it could change with time.

For pure aesthetics I have always been partial to biplanes, especially ones whose "line" can stand the test of time within my own view.  Mac-the-Bipe by Lloyd Curtis has always fit that mold for me.  It has the appearance of a Bucker Jungmeister or Stampe biplane which I have always admired.  It's on my "one of these days" list to build.  I don't believe its performance will be competitive with other classic designs but it sure will look good.

From a competitive performance perspective, I'll go with Bob Hunt's Caprice.  I have seen a few versions of this airplane fly in competitions from regional/local contests to the Nats, and it is a high performer in addition to having the aforementioned "line."  It is indeed a fine looking, fine performing airplane.

Kermit


Thanks for the shout out on the Caprice, Kermit! But to give credit where credit is due, I pretty much just restyled Gene Schaffer's Black Bird (a photo of that plane is posted in an above response). And, Gene always credited Charles Mackey for inspiring his early designs. I totally agree with you about the Classic era ships having the "line."

I'm hoping to spur renewed interest in the Classic Stunt event with this thread. The planes from the late 1950s and 1960s had a certain charm about them. Let's keep them flying...

Bob 

Ken Culbertson

Quote from: Clint Ormosen on February 15, 2026, 06:51:36 AM
My top three based on looks alone would be:

JD Falcon
Go no further.  Of all the designs from the 60's, my own included, the JD Falcon radiates "Stunt" more than any.  Some planes simply have that quality.  The "Bear" is another from more modern times.  The JD is the only plane I have ever purchased plans for. 

Ken
AMA 15382
If it is not broke you are not trying hard enough.
USAF 1968-1974 TAC

Bob Hunt

Quote from: Ken Culbertson on February 15, 2026, 08:41:31 AM
Go no further.  Of all the designs from the 60's, my own included, the JD Falcon radiates "Stunt" more than any.  Some planes simply have that quality.  The "Bear" is another from more modern times.  The JD is the only plane I have ever purchased plans for. 

Ken

Yet another great choice, Ken. I grew up on the East Coast watching a lot of fliers performing with J.D. Falcons. My mentor, Bill Simons, was a huge fan of the Falcon and had a couple of really beautiful versions. Here's an interesting note: The plans presented in the Model Airplane News article were not accurate to John's original. Tom Neibuhr got it right when he produced his Blue Sky Models kit of the J.D. Falcon.

Attached is a photo of John D'Ottavio with his original J.D. Falcon at the 1961 Mirror Meet at Floyd Bennet Field in Brooklyn, New York.

Later - Bob Hunt

   

Dave Hull

Bob--What was "inaccurate" about the published J.D. Falcon plans?

Bob Hunt

Quote from: Dave Hull on February 16, 2026, 07:36:03 PM
Bob--What was "inaccurate" about the published J.D. Falcon plans?

As I recall, Dave, the distance between the hinge lines was off by quite a bit from John's original. But there may have been other discrepancies. Tom Niebuhr would have the full answer for you, but, sadly - very sadly - he is no longer with us. I remember my mentor, Bill Simons telling me there were differences between the magazine plan and John's original. I've just -over the years - forgotten what they all were. I almost built one back in the 1960s, but opted to follow Gene Schaffer's design trends instead.

Later - Bob

Mark Scarborough

Don Shultz Avenger, my all time favorite!
Dont have a picture on this laptop though
For years the rat race had me going around in circles, Now I do it for fun!
EXILED IN PULLMAN WA
AMA 842137

Bob Hunt

Quote from: Mark Scarborough on February 18, 2026, 01:25:59 PM
Don Shultz Avenger, my all time favorite!
Dont have a picture on this laptop though

Yup! Another great choice, Mark. As you no doubt already know, the Avenger was inspired by Bob Gialdini's Sting Ray and Eclipse designs. There are just so many iconic designs out there that are worthy of being favorites.

LAter - Bob

Matt Colan

#25
Choice number 1 for the future. USA-1!! My current classic plane is a very close 2nd and flies great!!
Matt Colan

Jim Hoffman

Quote from: Matt Colan on February 20, 2026, 08:42:06 PMChoice number 1 for the future. USA-1!! My current classic plane is a very close 2nd and flies great!!

As the owner of a USA-1, I concur. It remains one of the best flying and friendliest models I've ever flown

Bob Hunt

Although never published, my Avanti design (named that well before Bob Baron's Avanti...) is fully Classic legal. It was also inspired by the "new wave" style airplanes of the late 1960s. It flew extremely well, but was short lived due to a tank rupture that soaked the inside of the fuselage. Up to that point I had not used removable tanks that rested in a compartment sealed off from the fuselage's interior. Predictably I started doing that with my very next airplane, the F-105 Thunderchief.

The Avanti had a stretched Chipmunk wing (higher aspect ratio), half span flaps (thank you Charles Mackey), trike gear with wheel pants (thank you Jim Van Loo), and it was powered by an OS Max H40S engine. It might be time for me to retire the Caprice and build a new Avanti! At least with electric I won't have to worry about fuel soakage...

Later - Bob

 

Bill Hummel

ama 72090

Bob Hunt

Thanks, Bill!

The Avanti was inspired (as was my later design, the Genesis) by the incredible designs I saw while attending the 1969 Nats in Willow Grove, PA. I think that everyone at that Nats were stunned by the number of fresh, modern designs that appeared on the flight line. I know that it had a huge impact on Gene Schaffer, Bill Simons and me. Gene's very next design after having seen those "new wave" ships at that Nats was his Oosa-Amma. Actually that airplane was not named by Gene. He rarely in those days gave his airplanes names. That ship had a huge "USA" on the left wing panel, and an equally huge "AMA' on the right wing panel. When he brought it to the Garden State Circle Burner's spring meet in 1970, Bill Simons asked him what the name meant. Gene, baffled, said "It doesn't have a name." Bill said, "It sure does, Oosa-Amma." Everyone there just laughed... Except Gene. He hated that name, but it stuck immediately when Bill coined it. And over time even Gene started calling it the Oosa-Amma.

The 1969 Nats was a turning point in stunt model design. More and more futuristic looking airplanes began showing up at stunt contests and in magazine articles. Th Avanti was my first expression of this new thinking. I now wish I had built another one and campaigned it. It was a great flying ship. In reality, I had so many new ideas at that time that I wanted to just design a lot of new airplanes. I still have the pencil drawing of that ship - faded a bit now - but something I might just revisit.   

Bob Hunt


Trostle

Quote from: Bob Hunt on February 28, 2026, 08:01:41 AMThanks, Bill!

The Avanti was inspired (as was my later design, the Genesis) by the incredible designs I saw while attending the 1969 Nats in Willow Grove, PA. I think that everyone at that Nats were stunned by the number of fresh, modern designs that appeared on the flight line. I know that it had a huge impact on Gene Schaffer, Bill Simons and me. Gene's very next design after having seen those "new wave" ships at that Nats was his Oosa-Amma. Actually that airplane was not named by Gene. He rarely in those days gave his airplanes names. That ship had a huge "USA" on the left wing panel, and an equally huge "AMA' on the right wing panel. When he brought it to the Garden State Circle Burner's spring meet in 1970, Bill Simons asked him what the name meant. Gene, baffled, said "It doesn't have a name." Bill said, "It sure does, Oosa-Amma." Everyone there just laughed... Except Gene. He hated that name, but it stuck immediately when Bill coined it. And over time even Gene started calling it the Oosa-Amma.

The 1969 Nats was a turning point in stunt model design. More and more futuristic looking airplanes began showing up at stunt contests and in magazine articles. Th Avanti was my first expression of this new thinking. I now wish I had built another one and campaigned it. It was a great flying ship. In reality, I had so many new ideas at that time that I wanted to just design a lot of new airplanes. I still have the pencil drawing of that ship - faded a bit now - but something I might just revisit.   

Bob Hunt



Bob,

What prop was that?

Keith

Dennis Adamisin

Weelllllll, I'm kinda fond of THIS one..!
Denny Adamisin
Fort Wayne, IN

As I've grown older, I've learned that pleasing everyone is impossible, but pissing everyone off is a piece of cake!

Bob Hunt

That was a Grish 10-5 nylon three blade prop. It worked okay, but not like today's props. Makes me wonder just how well some of those old designs might have flown with modern props and power. I know my latest Caprice is far superior to my first one that was flown back in 1967. The electric power, with modern electronic active control, and a light prop have made it something far beyond what I had back then.

Later - Bob

 

Bob Hunt

Quote from: Dennis Adamisin on March 01, 2026, 08:34:29 AMWeelllllll, I'm kinda fond of THIS one..!

Well... At least the airplane hasn't changed too much! All kidding aside, Denny is one of the premiere designing geniuses of our time. But, then again, he came from a family of modeling geniuses.

Bob Hunt

Gordon Tarbell

Gordon Tarbell AMA 15019

john e. holliday

Does any one here have one of Toms plans of the plane and the magazine plans.   It would be easy to compare them.  Like I have the magazine plans of the still Stuka and the kit plans of same plane.  A lot of differences in the plans.   The kit has every thing on a zero degree diviation between the thrust line, wing angle and stab mounting in fuselage.   The magazine shows all at a positive angle to the fuselage line.  LL three were stillat same angle to each other. In his coments if I remember right he stated that it made the fuselage line look level while flying level laps.  I have both plans and magazine in the shop some where.  Right now they won't let me out of the house with out my oxygin generater. I call it my ball and chain like some prisoners were attached to. D>K
John E. "DOC" Holliday
10421 West 56th Terrace
Shawnee, KANSAS  66203
AMA 23530  Have fun as I have and I am still breaking a record.

Bob Hunt

#36
Matt mentioned John Havel's Folkerts Speed King in an above post. That was indeed a gorgeous airplane. It was also suspiciously similar to George Aldrich's Magnum (no relation to the Sig Magnum). Not sure which came first, however...  ::)

Bob Hunt

Bob Hunt

#37
For those who might be interested, I have the distinct honor of being the person selected by the Scarinzi family to present Larry Scarinzi's Blue Angel, Sky Devil, and the original Super Satan combat ship to the AMA museum during Nats week this year. The presentation will happen at the replica hobby shop inside the museum on August 8th. The presentation will happen right after the PAMPA general meeting. If you are going to be attending the Nats, please make a special effort to be there to honor one of our hobby's greatest designer/builder/fliers.

Larry's Trident (also originally known as the "U-Name-It; a marketing gimmick by Consolidated Models, which kitted the airplane) was donated by the family to Pat Hartness, the owner of the Triple Tree Aerodrome in South Carolina. It will reside in Pat's museum there. Larry's long-time friend, Bruce Douglas transported the Trident to Triple Tree and made the presentation to Pat. That's Pat in the white shirt in the attached photo, and that's Bruce to his left in the photo with the sunglasses.

Later - Bob


Matt Neumann

I know this is going to come as a surprise but Don Still's Stuka comes to mind.  As well as Al Rabe's Bearcat and Mustang.  The originals that are classic legal.  I am drawn to scale like planes.
Matt Neumann



Advertise Here