News:

 

CLICK HERE--><--CLICK HERE

Not having fun with my Score

Started by Andrew Borgogna, May 28, 2008, 12:53:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Gordon Tarbell

Is that enya a drop in for the newer G51 or older v case 51?
Gordon Tarbell AMA 15019

Andrew Borgogna

To All
I didn't get a chance to fly the Score this past weekend.  Our club "Knights of the Round Circle" held its annual joust contest.  Because I am working on Saturdays I had to compete in Advance on Sunday, please don't ask how I did.  Oh well I took my Stuka Stunt home in one piece.  Anyway I plan to take the Score out again this coming weekend and first on the list of "things to do" is a series of short flight gradually moving the leadouts forward and testing the results with vertical eights.  If the pull improves to a equal pull through the entire vertical eight I will move to the overhead eight.  Once I have faith in both I will work on lap speeds by changing prop and/or line length.  I will let you all know how things turn out on Monday.
Thanks Again
Andy
Andrew B. Borgogna

Mike Scholtes

Hi Gordon:

The ST51 I have is the current Chinese-made version. I did have to drill out the holes in the plastic/glass RC-type mounts to use larger (6-32?) mounting bolts but the bolt pattern is the same. I had to enlarge the fiberglas cowl openings for the slightly different exhaust (using Randy Smith tube muffler) stack location and the needle valve is also different (one could say in the "right" place) on the Enya compared to the ST. Prop shaft length is also very close to same, so no problem with prop/cowl clearance.

The 61CXS Pro looks very well made and starts first flip when propped backwards against compression. Look forward to more test flights and trying different props. Currently using Zinger Pro 12-5, 9400 revs at launch.

Balsa Butcher


"The 61CXS Pro looks very well made and starts first flip when propped backwards against compression. Look forward to more test flights and trying different props. Currently using Zinger Pro 12-5, 9400 revs at launch."

Any more details?  Inquiring minds want to know   #^
Pete Cunha
Sacramento CA.
AMA 57499

Andrew Borgogna

61CXS Pro

For the heck of it I went over to Enya to look at this engine.  It seems the 61CXS Pro is very popular engine, "Sold Out".   :(
Andrew B. Borgogna

Steve Helmick

Quote from: Andrew Borgogna on June 08, 2008, 10:47:56 AM
61CXS Pro

For the heck of it I went over to Enya to look at this engine.  It seems the 61CXS Pro is very popular engine, "Sold Out".   :(

Check with Randy Smith and Kaz Minato and the dude in the Canary Islands...all stock Enya stunt engines.  I've heard good things about the service from all three.  y1 Steve
"The United States has become a place where professional athletes and entertainers are mistaken for people of importance." - Robert Heinlein

In 1944 18-20 year old's stormed beaches, and parachuted behind enemy lines to almost certain death.  In 2015 18-20 year old's need safe zones so people don't hurt their feelings.

Leo Mehl

Quote from: Steve Helmick on June 08, 2008, 08:14:36 PM
Check with Randy Smith and Kaz Minato and the dude in the Canary Islands...all stock Enya stunt engines.  I've heard good things about the service from all three.  y1 Steve
Got my Enyas from all three sources and the best service was from  Kaz Minato and Randy Smith. The third guy took a little longer but acceptiable. HB~>

Leo Mehl

Quote from: Stan Bidowski on May 29, 2008, 06:25:40 AM
Possibly try an APC 12.25 x 3.75 prop.  Your lap speed is way too high.  Definitely try the 13 x4, it will
help some, but the diameter might be a bit big for the .51.  Try it at 13 inch first, and then trim it
to 12.5 inches in diameter.  Small changes make a big difference.  The Mac's muffler will work good
only with low pitch props.  No wonder it's pulling like a bear....
Let us now how it goes.
                    http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin/wti0001p?&I=LX1577&P=M
Stan Bidowski
I am running a 12/6 on my st46 on a heavy Nobler.

Chris Edinger

Wow.... I just bought a Score.. and a new ST51 (China)... read the instructions which stated that the T/F folks flew theirs with OS 46LA.... and it flew fine.. they stated a 51 may overpower the plane... I Was thinking about using my italian ST46 G21..... now Im totally confused...  HB~> HB~>  Andrew.. keep me posted as to how this works out.. I havent Installed any engine yet... Thanks...

Chris
Lee's Summit MO
AMA 896082

Jim Oliver

Chris,
Don't believe a word of that drivel..........  ::) 

My first Score weighs ~64 oz. and my Tom Dixon ST 51 is short on Torque to handle it.  Yes, it will "fly", and not too bad in calm conditions, but scary in any wind.

I plan to up the nitro as a last resort before replacing the ST 51 with something larger.

My second Score will have serious torque from the beginning----I plan to use it to learn how to run a PA 75. ~^

Cheers,
Jim
Jim Oliver
AMA 18475

Joe Gilbert

Only played with a couple of the Tiger 51 and after lots of different props the Thunder tiger 12.5 by 5.5 was the best on both planes . Didn't try any of the high priced Bolly or Eather they might be better? Ran the engined in a hared four stroke and would break to two going up hill. Ran pantie hose filter on 5% nitro 22% oil half and half. Andrew if you can take some flap out of the plane do so, they work very well but slow it down in turns. If weight dictates you you need them, like if it stalls in turns, you cant take some out but only use what you need of them.
Joe Gilbert

Mike Scholtes

Chris:

I am still having plenty of fun with my Score! I intially ran it with the current (Chinese) ST51 with a Bowman ring and some rework and a Randy Smith tube muffler. This seemed to be plenty of power for the 65-oz finished weight. You should save yourself some headaches and time by checking the archives on Stuka for mods to this fine model.

I have about 20 flights on the Enya 61 CXS Pro in the Score and have nothing but praise for the engine. If primed right it is a reliably first-flip starter. Using a Randy Smith tube muffler (no the one for the ST does not fit). Great power on the verticals. Am using 9100 as launch rpm now on a 12-5 Zinger Pro, Sig 10-10-10 fuel, Enya #3 plug. Uses about 5.5 oz for the full pattern with a margin for safety.

Having several LA46s, I do not think they have the power for this large a model. Great engines though.

Jim Oliver

I flew the 64 oz. Score with the Tom Dixon ST 51 today; Zinger 12x5, both sq. tip and Zinger Pro. 
Sig 15 % nitro/20% oil with take of rpm set to 9100.  Sixty five X .018 lines, 5.1 lap times.  Wind was about
5 to 13 mph.

The biggest problem was some wind-up during the inside and outside rounds; and the guy at the handle....

I think the ST was doing about all it can do, and the plane would perform better with an engine that wasn't running flat out all the time. At the 9100 rpm setting, there is a little needle left, but not much.

So, time to get out the hammer and saw........

Cheers,
Jim
Jim Oliver
AMA 18475

Mike Scholtes

you may be interested to know the Enya 61 Pro is a direct drop-in for the ST51. Didn't have to change much except a few cowl openings for clearance. Prop shaft is close to same length. Just another option if you want more oomph.

Stan Bidowski

  Just to clarify what I typed here earlier, a 4.5 sec lap time is flying too fast, 5.2 or slower is more
like it.  At 4.5 sec lap times, a heavy model will pull hard, especially in level flight.  Also, remember
it was stated a MACS muffler, which is a mini PIPE, was being used.  Using a mini PIPE will demand
the use of a lower pitch prop.

Check out previous issues of Stunt News, were the MACS mini pipe was used with a .40 ( FP or was it
an LA 40 ?).  A low pitch prop was used with good success.  A stock .51 engine is being used, not a re timed
one, and not a ST .46 which requires nothing, no rework, and run fine on a 12 x 6.  Sorry, NOT a good
comparison to a 'PIPED' STOCK ST .51 . 

   Another option is to try flying the Score with out the 'muffler pipe', and a 5 or 6 pitch prop, like others
have here have used with success.  BUT once you add the MACS Muffler ( which is a mini pipe ), you
should be using a low pitch prop, and try to run as much diameter as the motor will turn. 

Stan Bidowski
MAAC 17167

Steve Helmick

Gary Dubois brought his "Score" out to Tacoma Narrows Airport today, complete with a stock Chinese G.51. While we weren't exactly thrilled with the engine run (at all), it doesn't seem to lack power. The line tension up top seems to be good enough, according to Gary, who is around 70 years old. He pretty much flies it like a combat model...

It needs some tank work (uniflow, but no forward ram air pickup or muffler pressure), has a tongue muffler and a 12-5 APC. We tried to get him to put on the 12.25 x 3.75 APC, but no soap. I think the nose end needs some wood in it, to absorb vibration. The plane makes a funny humming noise in flight...not sure what that is...if yours has a weird hum, and you find a solution, please let us know. Maybe the cowl or wheels or something harmless. Or not...  S?P Steve
"The United States has become a place where professional athletes and entertainers are mistaken for people of importance." - Robert Heinlein

In 1944 18-20 year old's stormed beaches, and parachuted behind enemy lines to almost certain death.  In 2015 18-20 year old's need safe zones so people don't hurt their feelings.

jim welch

Try this...saito 62a,65 foot lines,Apc 13-6 prop,20 20 powermaster 4 stroke fuel,line guides way foreward,engine straight on center line.What I got is 5.0 sec laps,great line tension everywhere and the best flying learning machine i've had to date.8400 Rpm at launch leaves a nice contrail againt the tree line.I have the same set up on my Magnum and it's a great flyer too.   JIM
AMA 89335

Martin Quartim


We have been using much bigger props with the Enya 61CX. This engine works amazingly well with a Bolly 13x4.5 3 Blades, 8.0mm venturi and Aeroproducts muffler. My Friend has one on a 74oz Strega, and the Enya 61CX  pulls it like there is nothing there, no matter if it is windy, no wind at all, or if its hot, windy and raining.

If you don't want to use a high performance carbon fiber prop, try an APC 13x4W or 14x4W. I haven't tried these APC props but I believe the engine has that much torque with the 8.0mm venturi to spin the 14x4W. For sure the 13x4W will be an easy load for the Enya with stock 7.5mm venturi.


Martin

Old Enya's never die, they just run stronger!

https://www.youtube.com/user/martinSOLO

Brett Buck

Quote from: Andrew Borgogna on May 28, 2008, 12:53:57 PM
I really thought the TF Score would be the plane I would be able to make serious progress in taking the pattern to the next level.  Truth is it just isn't happening.  I cannot get the trim sorted out.  At stright and level flight the Score darn near pulls my arm out of the socket, but at 45 degrees the pull falls off by more than half.  Overhead eights, verticle eights and hourglass range from  problematic at best to down right scary. 

    That's usually a sign of too much yaw angle, either rudder offset, or line sweep, or both. I think the procedure to use to get it close is pretty well documented, but if that doesn't fix it, it would help tremendously if you could get a local expert to look at it carefully. If it pulls hard in level flight, and the power doesn't grossly drop off overhead, it should pull pretty good overhead, too, if everything is nice and square.

    I haven't been very impressed with the Score. It looks like it ought to be pretty good from the parts,  if a bit heavy, but for whatever reason I haven't seen one that looked very good from the outside, and the two I have flown were really handfuls. Eric Rogers has an electric version that looked pretty decent when he flew it, but Ted flew it and seemed to have his hands full in level flight. I got a chuckle out of that, until I flew it and almost crashed in level flight at almost the same point in the flight he had trouble. I should have known better, if Ted can't make it look good, I haven't got much of a chance.

     Brett

     

Bob Reeves

I wouldn't give up on the Score.. Several "Experts" have flown mine and were actually quite impressed. Maybe I just got lucky or could be the care I took making sure everything was straight and true when I assembled it. It doesn't hum and with the 4 stroke I'm sure I would hear it, do have to say I believe allot of it's good qualities are due to the brute power of the Saito 56 in the nose.

It has slowly succeeded in undressing itself and at the end of last season decided I either had to hang it up or recover it. It's waiting for me to get finished with the new ship then will get recovered. It's just too good an airplane to hang up.

Brett Buck

Quote from: Bob Reeves on February 20, 2009, 02:56:38 AM
I wouldn't give up on the Score.. Several "Experts" have flown mine and were actually quite impressed. Maybe I just got lucky or could be the care I took making sure everything was straight and true when I assembled it. It doesn't hum and with the 4 stroke I'm sure I would hear it, do have to say I believe allot of it's good qualities are due to the brute power of the Saito 56 in the nose.

  I have to admit to not having spent a lot of time trying to figure out what the problem was with the models I flew. I am reasonably sure that there isn't anything intrinsically wrong with the airplane design, but as you say, the details are what matters. I tend to agree with the observation of needing a fair bit of power to fly well, not surprising given that they are frequently in the 75-80 oz range. I would think the Saito 56 is near the bottom of the scale for that weight airplane, even granting that you seem to have a better setup than most. Certainly an ST51 is marginal unless you really lean on it.

     Brett



Mike Scholtes

Brett, I will bring mine up to Woodland this spring and you can try one with an Enya 61CXS at 65 ounces. Certainly I am not in your league of piloting skills but it seems pretty darn good, squares the corners well and (to me) grooves well too. All controls replaced with ball links and carbon pushrods, proper hinges, the works. Once leadouts were adjusted the line tension is good but not excessive at all points on the hemisphere. The controls are too fast (used a 3" bellcrank, what was I thinking) but maybe good combined with my slower reflexes!

Brett Buck

Quote from: Mike Scholtes on February 20, 2009, 11:34:40 PM
Brett, I will bring mine up to Woodland this spring and you can try one with an Enya 61CXS at 65 ounces. Certainly I am not in your league of piloting skills but it seems pretty darn good, squares the corners well and (to me) grooves well too. All controls replaced with ball links and carbon pushrods, proper hinges, the works. Once leadouts were adjusted the line tension is good but not excessive at all points on the hemisphere. The controls are too fast (used a 3" bellcrank, what was I thinking) but maybe good combined with my slower reflexes!

    I'll certainly give it a try!   A 60 certainly seems like the right kind of power.

     Brett

Martin Quartim


I hope you guys have a chance to try a bigger prop with low pitch with Socre/Enya 61CX.
You have no idea what you are missing. It runs like a pipe engine kicking higher rpms in the overheads. So far the best prop we have tried was the Bolly 13x4.5 3 Blade.

I can't understand how you manage to run this engine with a 12x5 prop using Randy's Muffler. I could understand if you were using the original muffler.

When we tried the Zinger 13x5 we found it was not enough prop for it. We had to run the engine so rich that it burbled a lot on the inside corners. As matter of fact, only the Enya 3 plug would keep the engine running, the engine would quit with other plugs including the TB w/ idle bar.

This is a video of a test flight we did using a Bill Werwage P-47 (over 70oz) with the Zinger 13x5, launch at around 8400rpms,  the sound does not show how much the engine was burbling rich..but you can notice how much the plane slows down on the exit of the wingover.


We could needle the engine pass 10k rpms with the Zinger 13x5 and it sound happier above 9500rpms, but of course we couldn't fly in these rpms with this prop.

Windy has flown my friends Strega with the Enya 61CX and was impressed with the engine power and still the best prop was not used becaue it was not available. My friend only had a 12.5x5.5 3Blades CF prop and also had to run the engine too rich to keep speeds down even with 70' lines. The same way, the engine would run only with the Enya 3 plug and choke a lot on the inside corners, other then that was a great run with incredible overhead power. Windy said he wished he had that engine on the P-47 he was flying at the contest here in Sao Paulo, and what he had was a 70 4 stroke.

Martin
Old Enya's never die, they just run stronger!

https://www.youtube.com/user/martinSOLO

Mike Scholtes

Hi Martin:

This is good information! I am still in the early stages of experimenting with props on the 61CXS and welcome anyone else's input and experiences. It runs fine with the 12x5 Zinger Pro but I want to try some larger props. I don't know if this is an engine that wants to run fast on a flat prop, or slower on a higher pitch prop. I am kind of splitting the difference. I fly off a fairly rough field that is death on $50 carbon props so I will stick to wood and plastic for now. The APC 13x4W sounds interesting; I will order one and a 13x5 (if they make one) and give it a go.


Advertise Here