Larry,
That is a really good looking plane. It is unfortunate that the finish won't harder. Before going to all the work of refinishing, try heating the finish. Epoxy, even when not properly catalyzed will often harden when heated. If the other half will let you, put it in a pre-heated oven at around 150 to 200 deg. F. Start at the low end and increase (not with the plane in the oven as some use the broiler element to heat the oven... no infra red just heated air) it if needed. You haven't got much to loose and it may just work.
Orv.