In my early years I used Aerogloss simply because that's what the LHS had on the shelves. I'd use it straight from the jar or can and thought it worked well, but at the time I didn't know any better. I do remember it lifting off of fillets with regularity.
Later, I discovered Sig dope. It was shortly after that when I learned about thinning dope and thus, using it "properly". Overall, I liked the Sig better than the Aerogloss and I used it for years.
These days (roughly the past 6-8 years) I use Brodak and Randolph exclusively. To me, especially with the colors, it doesn't even compare to the other two. The pigments seem a LOT better and coverage is much, much better. I'd have a real hard time finding a reason to try anything else.